Positive Some critics have argued that AutoTune opens up new possibilities in pop music, especially in
hip-hop and
R&B. Instead of using it as a correction tool for poor vocals—its original purpose—some musicians intentionally use the technology to mediate and augment their artistic expression. When the electronic duo
Daft Punk was questioned about their use of AutoTune in their single "
One More Time",
Thomas Bangalter replied, "A lot of people complain about musicians using AutoTune. It reminds me of the late '70s when musicians in France tried to ban the synthesizer... They didn't see that you could use those tools in a new way instead of just for replacing the instruments that came before."
T-Pain, the
R&B singer and rapper who reintroduced the use of AutoTune as a vocal effect in pop music with his album
Rappa Ternt Sanga in 2005, said, "My dad always told me that anyone's voice is just another instrument added to the music. There was a time when people had seven-minute songs, and five minutes were just straight instrumental. ... I got a lot of influence from [the '60s era]. I thought I might as well turn my voice into a saxophone." Following in T-Pain's footsteps,
Lil Wayne experimented with AutoTune between his albums
Tha Carter II and
Tha Carter III. At the time, he was heavily addicted to
promethazine codeine, and some critics see AutoTune as a musical expression of Wayne's loneliness and depression.
Mark Anthony Neal wrote that Lil Wayne's vocal uniqueness, his "slurs, blurs, bleeps and blushes of his vocals, index some variety of trauma." And Kevin Driscoll asks, "Is AutoTune not the
wah pedal of today's black pop? Before he transformed himself into T-Wayne on "
Lollipop", Wayne's pop presence was limited to guest verses and unauthorized freestyles. In the same way that Miles equipped
Hendrix to stay pop-relevant, Wayne's flirtation with the VST plugin du jour brought him updial from
JAMN 94.5 to
KISS 108."
Kanye West's
808s & Heartbreak was generally well received by critics, and it similarly used AutoTune to represent a fragmented soul, following his mother's death. The album marks a departure from his previous album,
Graduation. Describing the album as a breakup album,
Rolling Stone music critic
Jody Rosen wrote, "Kanye can't really sing in the classic sense, but he's not trying to. T-Pain taught the world that AutoTune doesn't just sharpen flat notes: It's a painterly device for enhancing vocal expressiveness and upping the pathos ... Kanye's digitized vocals are the sound of a man so stupefied by grief, he's become less than human."
YouTuber Conor Maynard, who received criticism for his use of AutoTune, defended it in an interview on the
Zach Sang Show in 2019, stating: "It doesn't mean you can't sing ... AutoTune can't make anyone who can't sing sound like they can sing ... It just tightens it up slightly because we're human and not perfect, whereas [AutoTune] is literally digitally perfect."
Negative At the
51st Grammy Awards in 2009, the band
Death Cab for Cutie made an appearance wearing blue ribbons to protest the use of AutoTune. Later that year,
Jay-Z titled the lead single of his album
The Blueprint 3 as "
D.O.A. (Death of AutoTune)". Jay-Z said he wrote the song because of personal beliefs that the trend had become a gimmick that had become too widely used.
Christina Aguilera appeared in public in Los Angeles on August 10, 2009, wearing a T-shirt that read "Auto Tune is for Pussies". When interviewed by
Sirius/XM, she said AutoTune could be used "in a creative way" and noted her song "Elastic Love" from
Bionic uses it. Opponents have argued that AutoTune has a negative effect on society's perception and consumption of music. In 2004, the
Daily Telegraph music critic Neil McCormick called AutoTune a "particularly sinister invention that has been putting an extra shine on pop vocals since the 1990s" by taking "a poorly sung note and transpos[ing] it, placing it dead centre of where it was meant to be". In 2006, the singer-songwriter
Neko Case said a studio employee once told her that she and
Nelly Furtado were the only singers who had never used it in his studio. Case said "it's cool that she has some integrity". In 2009,
Time quoted an unnamed Grammy-winning recording engineer as saying, "Let's just say I've had AutoTune save vocals on everything from
Britney Spears to
Bollywood cast albums. And every singer now presumes that you'll just run their voice through the box." The same article expressed "hope that pop's fetish for uniform perfect pitch will fade", speculating that pop-music songs have become harder to differentiate from one another, as "track after track has perfect pitch". According to
Tom Lord-Alge, AutoTune is used on nearly every record these days. In 2010, the reality TV show
The X Factor admitted to using AutoTune to improve the voices of contestants. Also in 2010,
Time included AutoTune in their list of "The 50 Worst Inventions". Heavily used by stars like
Snoop Dogg,
Lil Wayne and
Britney Spears, AutoTune has been criticized as indicative of an inability to
sing on key.
Trey Parker used AutoTune on the
South Park song "
Gay Fish", and found that he had to sing off-key in order to sound distorted; he said, "You had to be a bad singer in order for that thing to actually sound the way it does. If you use it and sing into it correctly, it doesn't do anything to your voice." The singer
Kesha has used AutoTune in her songs extensively, putting her vocal talent under scrutiny. In 2009, the producer
Rick Rubin wrote that "Right now, if you listen to pop, everything is in perfect pitch, perfect time and perfect tune. That's how ubiquitous AutoTune is." The
Time journalist
Josh Tyrangiel called Auto-Tune "
Photoshop for the human voice".
Ellie Goulding and
Ed Sheeran have called for honesty in live shows by joining the "Live Means Live" campaign. "Live Means Live" was launched by songwriter/composer
David Mindel. When a band displays the "Live Means Live" logo, the audience knows, "there's no AutoTune, nothing that isn't 100 percent live" in the show, and there are no
backing tracks. In 2023, multiple creators on the social media platform
TikTok were accused of using AutoTune in post-production to correct the pitch of singing videos presented to appear as live, casual performances. == Impact and parodies ==