Born in
Cloquet, Minnesota, Payton was the daughter of Erwin Lee ("Flip") and Mabel Irene (née Todahl) Redfield, the daughter of Norwegian immigrants and one of six siblings. They opened a combination ice cream store and restaurant in
Little Falls, Minnesota. As early as age 11, Payton gained attention in the community for her appearance, even among middle-aged men. Her mother encouraged this type of attention due to her pride in her daughter's looks. In school, Payton excelled in history and English, tumbling, and many years of ceramics, purportedly having a talent for "creating beautiful objects from scratch." In November 1943, the then-16-year-old eloped with high-school boyfriend William Hodge. The marriage seemingly amounted to nothing more than an act of impulsive teenage rebellion, and Payton did not fight her parents' insistence that the marriage be annulled. A few months later, she quit high school in the 11th grade. Her parents, who did not believe that formal education was needed for success in life, did not object to her leaving high school without a diploma. In 1944, Payton met her second husband, decorated combat pilot John Payton, stationed at
Midland Army Airfield. The couple was married on February 10, 1945, and moved to
Los Angeles, where John Payton enrolled at
University of Southern California under the
G.I. Bill. Still early in their marriage, Payton, restless and feeling confined by her life as a housewife, expressed a desire to pursue a modeling or acting career. Payton started a modeling career by hiring a photographer to take photos of her sporting fashionable outfits. This portfolio attracted the attention of
Saba of California, a clothing designer, which signed her to a contract modeling a new line of junior fashions called
Sue Mason Juniors. In September 1947, the
Rita La Roy Agency in Hollywood took her on and brought her work in print advertising, notably in catalogs for
Studebaker cars and in clothing ads for magazines such as
Charm and
Junior Bazaar. The couple had a son, John Lee (1947–2023), on March 14, 1947. Payton managed to combine the responsibilities of wife, new mother, and professional model, yet the marriage was strained, and the couple separated in July 1948. Payton's drive, fueled by her high-energy personality, had become focused on promoting her career and showcasing her around the town's hot spots. Her notoriety as a luminous, fun-loving party girl in the Hollywood club scene caught the attention of
William Goetz, an executive of Universal Studios. In January 1949, he signed her at age 21 to a contract with a starting salary of $100 per week. After her divorce from John Payton in 1950, she lost custody of their son in March 1956 after her ex-husband charged that she exposed John Lee to "profane language, immoral conduct, notoriety, unwholesome activities" and failed to provide the boy with a "moral education". ==Career==