1986–1996 After arriving in the majors, Larkin battled fellow prospect
Kurt Stillwell for the starting shortstop spot before establishing himself as the starter in 1987. In 1988, Larkin led all major leaguers by striking out only 24 times in 588 at-bats. Larkin was not selected as an All-Star in 1992, but he won his fifth consecutive
Silver Slugger Award. In 1995, Larkin finished sixth in batting (.319) and second in stolen bases (51) to win the National League's
MVP award, the first by a shortstop since
Maury Wills in 1962. He led the Reds to the
National League Central division title and the
National League Championship Series, where he batted .389 during the series loss to the
eventual champion Atlanta Braves. He arguably had a better season in 1996 than he had in his MVP year of 1995, as his
on-base percentage and
slugging percentage were both improved.
1997–2000 Larkin was named the Reds' captain before the 1997 season, making him the first player to hold the honor since
Dave Concepción's retirement. Beginning that season, Larkin suffered a series of injuries throughout the last few years of his career. He missed 55 games that year due to injuries to his calf and Achilles tendon. About three weeks before the opening of the 1998 season, Larkin decided to undergo neck surgery for a perforated disk. He was not in severe pain, but he was unable to lift his arm enough to play defense. On September 27, 1998, Barry, his brother
Stephen Larkin, second baseman
Bret Boone, and third baseman
Aaron Boone all played the infield at the same time for the last game of the 1998 season, making it the first time in MLB history that an infield was composed entirely of two pairs of brothers. In 1999, Larkin was nearly traded to the
Los Angeles Dodgers. He later said that he was approached by a Los Angeles clubhouse attendant, who gave him a Dodgers jersey with his name on it. The jersey had been prepared as trade negotiations advanced so that the teams could be prepared for a press conference about the trade. Also in 1999, Larkin served as a pre-game analyst for
NBC's coverage of the
World Series alongside host
Hannah Storm. In July 2000, Larkin blocked a trade to the
New York Mets to remain with the Reds. The trade would have sent three players, top minor league outfielder
Alex Escobar, pitcher
Eric Cammack and pitcher Jason Saenz, from the Mets to the Reds in exchange for Larkin. Larkin said that he would have gone to New York, as he enjoyed playing there, but the Mets did not want to sign him to a multi-year contract. The Reds signed him to a three-year contract extension worth $27 million. In the 2000 season, Larkin missed 59 games after he injured his finger twice and he suffered a knee sprain. He underwent finger surgery in April and knee surgery in September.
2001–2004 Larkin struggled with a groin injury in 2001, prompting criticism of his play. Broadcaster
Joe Nuxhall said on air that Larkin had "lost it". By August, the injury had limited Larkin to 45 games. He underwent season-ending surgery for a hernia that had been diagnosed during an evaluation of the groin injury. In 2003, Larkin had spent two stints on the disabled list with calf injuries by late May. Commenting on Larkin's retirement after such a strong season, sports columnist
Terence Moore drew a comparison to the retirement of
Ted Williams. He wrote, "Barry Larkin wasn't quite Williams at the end, but he was in the vicinity when it comes to the big picture... After years of injuries, he showed what a healthy Larkin still could do, but he also showed that he preferred to leave the game more like Williams than just about anybody else you can name in baseball history." In his 19-year career with Cincinnati, Larkin hit .295 with 2,340
hits, 198 home runs, 960
RBI, 1,329
runs scored, and 379 stolen bases. Baseball writer
Bill James has called Larkin one of the greatest shortstops of all time, ranking him #6 all time in his
New Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract. Despite missing significant playing time in six seasons, Larkin won the
Gold Glove Award three times (1994–1996) and was a 12-time All-Star (1988–1991, 1993–1997, 1999, 2000, and 2004). ==Post-retirement==