Each year different sets of All-American teams are recognized toward consensus and unanimous selection recognition. A "unanimous selection" is a player who is listed as a first team All-American by all recognized lists. A "consensus All-American" is a player who is listed as a first team All-American by at least half of the recognized lists. All-America teams are selected annually in various collegiate sports.
Archery In collegiate archery competitions All-America selections are determined by the US Collegiate Archery (USCA) association. All-American honors are awarded for Olympic Recurve, Compound Target, and Bowhunter divisions. All-American honors are awarded to the top 10 archers in each division based on aggregate scores from the National Indoor and Intercollegiate Championships each year.
Baseball In
baseball, All-America teams are selected annually by the
American Baseball Coaches Association and
Collegiate Baseball.
Basketball In
Division I men's basketball, the
National Collegiate Athletic Association recognizes consensus All-America teams via a points system, currently based on teams chosen by four entities: the
Associated Press (AP), the
National Association of Basketball Coaches,
Sporting News, and the
United States Basketball Writers Association (USBWA). Many other bodies and publications select their own All-America teams. In Division I women's basketball, the NCAA recognizes unanimous first-team selections since 1995 based on selections from the AP, USBWA and
Women's Basketball Coaches Association.
Cross country running Selections are administered by the
U.S. Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association (USTFCCCA). In Division I, the top 40 overall finishers at the national meet are all named to the All-America team. In Division III, as of 2017, the top 40 finishers garner All-American distinction (previously top 35). The student-athlete's team must be a member of the USTFCCCA.
Fencing Based on the
NCAA Fencing Championships, the
U.S. Fencing Coaches Association annually selects athletes for All-American first team, second team, third team, and honorable mention titles.
Football The
National Collegiate Athletic Association currently recognizes
All-America college football teams selected by the
Associated Press,
American Football Coaches Association,
Football Writers Association of America,
Sporting News, and the
Walter Camp Football Foundation (WCFF) to determine consensus All-Americans.
Golf All-American honors are awarded by the
GCAA for men's golf.
Gymnastics In NCAA men's gymnastics, all American status is awarded to the top 8 finishers in the national championship.
Ice hockey The
American Hockey Coaches Association (AHCA) selects All-Americans at the Division I and Division III levels, for both men and women. For Division I men, they select a first- and a second-team for East and for West; for Division I women, they select national first- and second-teams. For Division III men, they select a first- and a second-team for East and for West; for Division III women, they select a first and second team for both East and West.
Lacrosse The
United States Intercollegiate Lacrosse Association (USILA) annually selects
men's lacrosse All-Americans, distinguished by first team, second team, third team, and honorable mention. The Intercollegiate Women's Lacrosse Coaches Association (IWLCA) annually selects women's lacrosse All-Americans, distinguished by first team, second team, third team, and honorable mention.
US Lacrosse, the national governing body for men's and women's lacrosse, annually selects national boys' and girls' high school All-Americans.
Rowing The
American Collegiate Rowing Association (ACRA) and
Collegiate Rowing Coaches of America (CRCA) name All-American teams for men and women respectively.
Rugby union The term
All-America was used for the student rugby teams that toured Australia in 1912 and New Zealand in 1913, see
Rugby union in the United States.
Sailing The
Inter-Collegiate Sailing Association (ICSA) selects All-American teams annually at the end of every full racing season. The selected sailors are then inducted into the ICSA Hall of Fame.
Soccer In
soccer,
United Soccer Coaches (formerly known as the National Soccer Coaches Association of America, or NSCAA) annually names an
eleven-member All-America team, as well as Division I women, and Division II and III teams.
Swimming and diving In NCAA
swimming and
diving, athletes and relay teams who make the championship final (top eight) are considered First-Team All-Americans. Athletes and relay teams that qualify for the consolation final (determines places 9–16) are considered Honorable Mention All-Americans. All-American teams are selected by the College Swimming Coaches Association of America (CSCAA).
Tennis The
Intercollegiate Tennis Association annually selects men's and women's D-1 players with the following criteria SINGLES (denoted by 'S') 1.) Top 16 seed in NCAA Singles Championships, or 2.) Reach round of 16 in NCAA Singles Championships, or 3.) Finish in the Top 20 of the final ITA Rankings. DOUBLES (denoted by 'D') 1.) Top eight seed in NCAA Doubles Championships, or 2.) Reach quarterfinals of NCAA Doubles Championship, or 3.) Finish in Top 10 of final ITA Rankings.
Track and field Administered by the
U.S. Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association, the selection rule differs for
NCAA Division I compared to
NCAA Division II,
Division III,
NJCAA and
NAIA. For all categories, the top eight finishers in each individual event are awarded First-Team All-America designation, while Division I athletes placed ninth through sixteenth are awarded Second-Team. Relays are judged strictly on a top-eight basis. The cutoffs are the same for both indoor and outdoor competition. The student-athlete's team must be a member of the USTFCCCA, and relay members must run in the finals to earn All-America status. In
AIAW track and field before women's sports were added to the NCAA, All-America certificates were awarded to the top six athletes at the
national outdoor or
indoor championships per event.
Volleyball The
American Volleyball Coaches Association (AVCA) selects five NCAA All-America teams. In women's volleyball, it selects teams for all three NCAA divisions. In the men's game, teams are chosen in the National Collegiate division (which includes members of Division I and Division II) and in Division III. The AVCA also selects teams for the
NAIA,
USCAA and
NCCAA.
Wrestling In all
NCAA,
NAIA,
NJCAA,
NCWA, and
CCCAA divisions, the top 6 or 8 placers at the national championship tournament are considered All-Americans. ==High school sports==