Command The Confederate chain of command was
anomalous.
Lieutenant Catesby ap Roger Jones had directed much of the conversion of
Merrimack to
Virginia, and he was disappointed when he was not named her captain. Jones was retained aboard
Virginia, but only as her executive officer. Ordinarily, the ship would have been led by a captain of the Confederate States Navy, to be determined by the rigid seniority system that was in place. Secretary Mallory wanted the aggressive
Franklin Buchanan, but at least two other captains had greater seniority and had applied for the post. Mallory evaded the issue by appointing Buchanan, head of the Office of Orders and Detail, flag officer in charge of the defenses of Norfolk and the James River. As such, he could control the movements of
Virginia. Technically, therefore, the ship went into the battle without a captain. On the Union side, command of the
North Atlantic Blockading Squadron was held by
Flag Officer Louis M. Goldsborough. He had devised a plan for his frigates to engage
Virginia, hoping to trap her in their crossfire. In the event, his plan broke down completely when four of the ships ran aground (one of them intentionally) in the confined waters of the
roadstead. On the day of battle, Goldsborough was absent with the ships cooperating with the
Burnside Expedition in North Carolina. In his absence, leadership fell to his second in command, Captain
John Marston of . As
Roanoke was one of the ships that ran aground, Marston was unable to materially influence the battle, and his participation is often disregarded. Most accounts emphasize the contribution of the captain of
Monitor,
John L. Worden, to the neglect of others. Marston did, however, disregard orders from Secretary of War
Gideon Welles to send the
Monitor back to Washington, D.C., ahead of the battle, ensuring that it would be present to confront the
Merrimack.
March 8: Virginia wreaks havoc on wooden Union warships The battle began when the large and unwieldy CSS
Virginia steamed into Hampton Roads on the morning of March 8, 1862. Captain Buchanan intended to attack as soon as possible.
Virginia was accompanied from her moorings on the Elizabeth River by and , and was joined at Hampton Roads by the James River Squadron, , , and . When they were passing the Union batteries at Newport News,
Patrick Henry was temporarily disabled by a shot in her boiler that killed four of her crew. After repairs, she returned and rejoined the others. At this time, the Union Navy had five warships in the roadstead, in addition to several support vessels. The
sloop-of-war and frigate were anchored in the channel near Newport News. The sail frigate and the steam frigates and were near Fort Monroe, along with the
storeship . The latter three got under way as soon as they saw
Virginia approaching, but all soon ran aground.
St. Lawrence and
Roanoke took no further important part in the battle.
Virginia headed directly for the Union squadron. The battle opened when Union tug
Zouave fired on the advancing enemy, and
Beaufort replied. This preliminary skirmishing had no effect.
Virginia did not open fire until she was within easy range of
Cumberland. Return fire from
Cumberland and
Congress bounced off the iron plates without penetrating, although later some of
Cumberlands gunfire lightly damaged
Virginia.
Virginia rammed
Cumberland below the waterline and she sank rapidly, "gallantly fighting her guns as long as they were above water," according to Buchanan. She took 121 seamen down with her; those wounded brought the casualty total to nearly 150. Ramming
Cumberland nearly resulted in the sinking of
Virginia as well.
Virginias bow ram got stuck in the enemy ship's hull, and as
Cumberland listed and began to go down, she almost pulled
Virginia under with her. At the time the vessels were locked, one of ''Cumberland's
anchors was hanging directly above the foredeck of Virginia
. Had it come loose, the two ships might have gone down together. Virginia'' broke free, however, her ram breaking off as she backed away. Buchanan next turned
Virginia on
Congress. Seeing what had happened to
Cumberland, Lieutenant
Joseph B. Smith, captain of
Congress, ordered his ship grounded in shallow water. By this time, the
James River Squadron, commanded by
John Randolph Tucker, had arrived and joined
Virginia in the attack on
Congress. After an hour of unequal combat, the badly damaged
Congress surrendered. While the surviving crewmen of
Congress were being ferried off the ship, a Union battery on the north shore opened fire on
Virginia. In retaliation, Buchanan ordered
Congress fired upon with
hot shot, cannonballs heated red-hot.
Congress caught fire and burned throughout the rest of the day. Near midnight, the flames reached her magazine and she exploded and sank, stern first. Personnel losses included 110 killed or missing and presumed drowned. Another 26 were wounded, of whom ten died within days. Although she had not suffered anything like the damage she had inflicted,
Virginia was not completely unscathed. Shots from
Cumberland,
Congress, and Union troops ashore had riddled her smokestack, reducing her already low speed. Two of her guns were disabled and several armor plates had been loosened. Two of her crew were killed, and more were wounded. One of the wounded was Captain Buchanan, who stood out into the open top of the
Virginia, thinking it was perfectly safe, which led to him having his left thigh pierced by a rifle shot. Meanwhile, the
James River Squadron had turned its attention to
Minnesota, which had left
Fort Monroe to join in the battle and had run aground. but had killed 250 enemy sailors and had lost two. The Union had lost two ships and three were aground. The United States Navy's greatest defeat (which would remain so until
World War II) caused panic in Washington. As Lincoln's Cabinet met to discuss the disaster, the frightened
Secretary of War Edwin Stanton told the others that
Virginia might attack East coast cities, and even shell the
White House before the meeting ended. Welles assured his colleagues that they were safe as the ship could not traverse the Potomac River. He added that the Union also had an ironclad, and that it was heading to meet
Virginia.
March 9: Monitor engages Virginia Both sides used the respite to prepare for the next day.
Virginia put her wounded ashore and underwent temporary repairs. Captain Buchanan was among the wounded, so command on the second day fell to his executive officer, Lieutenant Catesby ap Roger Jones. Jones proved to be no less aggressive than the man he replaced. While
Virginia was being prepared for renewal of the battle, and while
Congress was still ablaze,
Monitor, commanded by Lieutenant John L. Worden, arrived in Hampton Roads. The Union ironclad had been rushed to Hampton Roads in hopes of protecting the Union fleet and preventing
Virginia from threatening Union cities. Captain Worden was informed that his primary task was to protect
Minnesota, so
Monitor took up a position near the grounded
Minnesota and waited. "All on board felt we had a friend that would stand by us in our hour of trial," wrote Captain Gershom Jacques Van Brunt,
Minnesotas commander, in his official report the day after the engagement. The next morning, at dawn on March 9, 1862,
Virginia left her anchorage at Sewell's Point and moved to attack
Minnesota, still aground. She was followed by the three ships of the James River Squadron. They found their course blocked, however, by the newly arrived
Monitor. At first, Jones believed the strange craft—which one Confederate sailor mocked as "a cheese on a raft"—to be a boiler being towed from the
Minnesota, not realizing the nature of his opponent. Soon, however, it was apparent that he had no choice but to fight her. The first shot of the engagement was fired at
Monitor by
Virginia. The shot flew past
Monitor and struck
Minnesota, which answered with a broadside; this began what would be a lengthy engagement. "Again, all hands were called to quarters, and when she approached within a mile of us I opened upon her with my stern guns and made a signal to the
Monitor to attack the enemy," Van Brunt added.
Monitors guns were used with the standard service charge of only of powder, which did not give the projectile sufficient momentum to penetrate her opponent's armor. Tests conducted after the battle showed that the
Dahlgren guns could be operated safely and efficiently with charges of as much as . However, despite this, as the two ironclads circled each other during the fight,
Monitor was about to penetrate
Virginia's armor, but a misfiring of her weapons caused her to lose the advantage. At 10 AM that morning,
Virginia grounded.
Monitor opened fire on her vulnerable adversary, yet
Virginia was able to scrape off the shore and rejoin the fight. Stodder was knocked unconscious and taken below, where it took him an hour to regain consciousness. Stodder thus became the first man injured during the battle. He was replaced by Stimers. The battle finally ceased when a shell from
Virginia struck the pilot house of
Monitor and exploded, driving fragments of paint and iron through the viewing slits into Worden's eyes and temporarily blinding him. Confederate Secretary of the Navy
Stephen Mallory wrote to Confederate President
Davis of the action: The conduct of the Officers and men of the squadron ... reflects unfading honor upon themselves and upon the Navy. The report will be read with deep interest, and its details will not fail to rouse the ardor and nerve the arms of our gallant seamen. It will be remembered that the
Virginia was a novelty in naval architecture, wholly unlike any ship that ever floated; that her heaviest guns were equal novelties in ordnance; that her motive power and obedience to her helm were untried, and her officers and crew strangers, comparatively, to the ship and to each other; and yet, under all these disadvantages, the dashing courage and consummate professional ability of Flag Officer Buchanan and his associates achieved the most remarkable victory which naval annals record. In Washington, belief that
Monitor had vanquished
Virginia was so strong that Worden and his men were awarded the thanks of Congress: Resolved ... That the thanks of Congress and the American people are due and are hereby tendered to Lieutenant J. L. Worden, of the United States Navy, and to the officers and men of the ironclad gunboat
Monitor, under his command, for the skill and gallantry exhibited by them in the remarkable battle between the
Monitor and the rebel ironclad steamer
Merrimack. During the two-day engagement, USS
Minnesota shot off 78 rounds of 10-inch solid shot; 67 rounds of 10-inch shells with 15-second fuse; 169 rounds of 9-inch solid shot; 180 9-inch shells with 15-second fuse; 35 8-inch shells with 15-second fuse and 5,567.5 pounds of service powder. Three crew members, Alexander Winslow, Henry Smith and Dennis Harrington were killed during the battle and 16 were wounded.
Spring 1862—a standoff at Hampton Roads Virginia remained in drydock for almost a month, getting repairs for battle damage as well as minor modifications to improve her performance. On April 4, she was able to leave drydock. Buchanan, still recovering from his wound, had hoped that Catesby Jones would be picked to succeed him, and most observers believed that Jones's performance during the battle was outstanding. The
seniority system for promotion in the Navy scuttled his chances, however, and the post went to the 67-year-old Commodore
Josiah Tattnall III.
Monitor, not severely damaged, remained on duty. Like his antagonist Jones, Greene was deemed too young to remain as captain; the day after the battle, he was replaced with Lieutenant
Thomas Oliver Selfridge Jr. Two days later, Selfridge was in turn relieved by Lieutenant
William Nicholson Jeffers. By late March, the Union blockade fleet had been augmented by hastily refitted civilian ships, including the powerful
SS Vanderbilt, , SS
Illinois, and SS
Ericsson. These had been outfitted with rams and some iron plating. By late April, the new ironclads
USRC E. A. Stevens and had also joined the blockade. Each side considered how best to eliminate the threat posed by its opponent, and after
Virginia returned each side tried to goad the other into attacking under unfavorable circumstances. Both captains declined the opportunity to fight in waters not of their own choosing; Jeffers in particular was under positive orders not to risk his ship. Consequently, each vessel spent the next month in what amounted to posturing.
Destruction of the combatants The end came first for
Virginia. Because the blockade was unbroken, Norfolk was of little strategic use to the Confederacy, and preliminary plans were laid to move the ship up the James River to the vicinity of Richmond. Before adequate preparations could be made, the Confederate Army under Major General
Benjamin Huger abandoned the city on May 9, without consulting anyone from the Navy.
Virginias draft was too great to permit her to pass up the river, which had a depth of only , and then only under favorable circumstances. She was trapped and could only be captured or sunk by the Union Navy. Rather than allow either, Tattnall decided to destroy his own ship. He had her towed down to Craney Island in Portsmouth, where the gang were taken ashore, and then she was set afire. She burned through the rest of the day and most of the following night; shortly before dawn, the flames reached her magazine, and she blew up.
Monitor likewise did not survive the year. She was ordered to
Beaufort, North Carolina, on Christmas Day, to take part in the blockade there. While she was being towed down the coast (under command of her fourth captain, Commander
John P. Bankhead), the wind increased and with it the waves; with no high sides, the
Monitor took on water. Soon the water in the hold gained on the pumps, and then put out the fires in her engines. The order was given to abandon ship; most men aboard were rescued by , but 16 went down with her when she sank in the early hours of December 31, 1862. == Aftermath ==