The later 2010s saw several storied traditional department store retailers update their brick-and-mortar formats after being encroached upon to a degree by several digital retailers in recent years. In June 2016, It was announced
Sears would shutter as part of an ongoing decision to phase out of their traditional brick-and-mortar format. In 2017, it was announced that
Rural King would begin renovating the previous Sears building and would open the following spring. On March 25, 2018, Rural King held a grand opening for its Beaver Valley Mall store. On January 3, 2017, it was announced that
Macy's would be closing their store at the mall as part of a plan of closing 68 underperforming stores nationwide. The store would close on March 26, 2017. In 2018, it was announced that the former Macy's building would be redeveloped into a new development called The Shops at Beaver Valley Mall, which was set to include additional retail, restaurants, as well as additional space for office, medical or other services by 2020. This development was postponed by the
COVID-19 pandemic, and instead it was converted into a U-Haul self storage center and the opening of a
Firehouse Subs. On April 3, 2025, the mall's only arcade, Aces Breakaway and Play, shut its doors after more than 30 years of being open in the mall. On June 5, 2025, it was announced that JCPenney would be closing at the mall on September 17, 2025, leaving Boscov's as the only tenant from the 1990s left. On March 29, 2026, it was announced that Dick's Sporting Goods would be closing their store at the mall on April 25, 2026, leaving Boscov's and Rural King as the mall's last traditional anchor tenants. == Chi-Chi's hepatitis A outbreak ==