Season 2 In the
second season of
Glee, Coach Beiste (
Dot-Marie Jones) is introduced as the new football coach for the McKinley High Titans in the premiere episode, "
Audition". He comes to William McKinley High with an enviable record of coaching successful football teams, and
Principal Figgins (
Iqbal Theba) boosts the football program budget to support the new coach by reducing the cheerleading and glee club budgets, which alarms coach
Sue Sylvester (
Jane Lynch) and director
Will Schuester (
Matthew Morrison), respectively, and drives them into a temporary alliance against Beiste. The coach is dismayed by their rudeness, but forgives Will when he apologizes and goes on to develop a friendship with him. Beiste contemplates resigning as coach upon learning that several students have been fantasizing about him in order to curb their arousal while making out. Will has the students apologize and earn Beiste's forgiveness. Will also learns that Beiste has never been kissed, which leads to him giving the coach a first kiss as a friendly gesture. He later helps the glee club members preserve
Brittany's (
Heather Morris) continued belief in Santa Claus: disguised as Santa, he explains to Brittany why her wish that paraplegic boyfriend
Artie (
Kevin McHale) be made to walk cannot be granted; later, Brittany anonymously receives a
ReWalk to allow Artie to walk for short periods of time. When antagonism flares between the football team's glee and non-glee factions, Beiste forces the entire football team to work together with the glee club for one week; despite encountering resistance and set-backs, the plan is ultimately successful and the team wins the championship game. During the episode "
Blame It on the Alcohol", Beiste takes Will out for a fun time at a rodeo bar, which includes the character's first lead vocal performance on the show in the duet "
One Bourbon, One Scotch, One Beer".
Season 3 In the third season, Beiste continues as football coach, and is recruited by Will to co-direct the school musical
West Side Story with guidance counselor
Emma Pillsbury (
Jayma Mays) and Artie. He orders the football team to play the Jets in the show. Beiste also takes on the task of running the school elections. In the episode "
The First Time", he begins dating Ohio State football recruiter Cooter Menkins (
Eric Bruskotter), who is scouting for talent at McKinley, but discovers in "
I Kissed a Girl" that Sue has become a rival for Cooter's affections just as Beiste begins to fall in love with him, thus prompting the character's first solo song, "
Jolene". He later tells Emma and Sue, in episode "
Yes/No", that he and Cooter have impulsively gotten married. A few months later, in the episode "
Choke", Beiste is hit by Cooter and given a black eye. Although initially convinced by Sue and Roz Washington (
NeNe Leakes) to leave for his own safety, the coach later returns home to give Cooter a second chance, before ultimately leaving him and giving back his wedding ring. The catalyst for the final break is
Puck (
Mark Salling), a football player and glee club member. Beiste stops a fight between Puck and another student: Puck is wielding a knife, and the coach berates him for doing something so stupid. Puck calls himself a loser, and starts crying; Beiste cries with him, saying that no one ever thinks the two of them hurt because they are "badasses", but they do. He arranges for Puck to retake a geography exam he flunked, which is keeping him from graduating high school, and helps him study for it; he passes and graduates. In the interim, he helps chaperone New Directions on their trip to Chicago, where they win the national show choir championship.
Season 4 Beiste first appears in "
The Role You Were Born to Play", helping Finn when he goes looking for a jock to play the lead in the school musical. He continues to advise Finn when Beiste takes charge of the glee club for the duration of Will's stay in Washington while he serves on a blue-ribbon arts panel. He also acts as faculty advisor to the school's superheroes club. When
Sam (
Chord Overstreet) and Brittany think the Mayan apocalypse is imminent and decide to get married, Beiste offers to marry them, but makes sure to perform a ceremony that is not valid legally. When the apocalypse does not happen, they are relieved when he tells them that they are not, in fact, married. Later in the season, after Emma leaves Will at the altar on their wedding day and the two are briefly estranged, Beiste confesses to falling in love with him, but he tells the coach that he and Emma have recently gotten back together. Will asks a hurt Beiste to come to glee club; he does so reluctantly, but as the period begins, two gunshots are heard in the school, and he assists in barricading the choir room, helping to keep everyone quiet, and aiding Will in subduing Sam when he wants to go out and search for Brittany, who was not in the room when the lockdown began. Afterward, Beiste tells Will that he should reach out to forgive Finn, whose role as Will's assistant on the glee club was terminated when Finn admitted to kissing Emma while Will was in Washington, and he does so.
Season 5 Finn's death hits Beiste hard, and when Puck comes into the locker room drunk, weeks after the funeral and saying that he is lost without Finn, Beiste tells him he needs to take charge of his life and give himself the advice and guidance he would have gotten from his best friend. The two cry over their loss. Later, the two gather at Finn's outdoor memorial at McKinley, which includes a tree that Puck had stolen as a memento and later replanted at Beiste's behest, and Puck tells the coach that he has decided to join the Air Force.
Season 6 In "
Jagged Little Tapestry," Beiste is acting strangely, worrying Sam Evans, who is now the assistant football coach, and principal Sue Sylvester. He ultimately meets with them both to explain he is suffering from
gender dysphoria and asks Sam to take over as football coach during his impending
transition to male. Sue promises Beiste her full support, and tells the coach that his position will be waiting for him on his return. He returns as Sheldon Beiste in "
Transitioning". ==Development==