Michelle Erica Green, in her 2011
TrekToday Retro Review said, "Conceptually" it was "a very interesting episode with a lot going on" such as the "cranky" colony creature, the "intelligent but primitive dinosaur 'aborigines'" who build prisons but whose language "is too unusual for the Universal Translator," a "godlike alien," and other "volatile situations" such as "an accidental first contact." Green felt that "none of it feels recycled" but rather that "the situation" turns out "entirely different than one might have expected from previous episodes." Even so, she said, "I don’t love this episode...despite the enjoyable pacing and some quick-witted dialogue," citing too much technobabble, and that "so much of the regular cast gets short shrift – McCoy and Chapel are absent, Scotty and Sulu serve as plot devices, Uhura has little to contribute," and that Kirk allowed Bem to "beam down to a planet with a pre-warp culture of unknown strength and intelligence," which was clearly a violation of the Prime Directive. However, Green appreciated "lots of giggle moments" and "the first pronouncement of James Tiberius Kirk’s full name" which was "not made canon until the original series movies." In 2017,
Tor.com rated this episode 8 out of 10, noting that the
Enterprise takes on the passenger Bem and goes to the planet Delta Theta III. == See also ==