The earliest known Bishop of Gubbio is Decentius, though a letter of
Pope Innocent I notes that he had predecessors.
Gregory the Great (590–604) entrusted to Bishop
Gaudiosus of Gubbio the spiritual care of
Tadinum, about a mile from the modern
Gualdo, which had been long without a bishop of its own. In the eighth century
Gubbio became part of the
Patrimony of St. Peter, together with the
duchy of Spoleto.
Arsenius of Gubbio (855) together with
Nicholas of Anagni, opposed the election of
Pope Benedict III. It was often at war with
Perugia, and its victory in 1151 over Perugia and ten other towns is famous.
St. Ubald, bishop of the city, directed the campaign. Gubbio favoured the
Ghibelline party; however, in 1260 the
Guelphs surprised the town, and drove out the Ghibellines; who returned again in 1300 under the leadership of
Uguccione della Faggiola, and
Federico I da Montefeltro, whereupon
Pope Boniface VIII sent his nephew Napoleone Orsini who drove them out once more. Giovanni Gabrielli, lord of Gubbio, was expelled by
Cardinal Albornoz (1354) and the town handed over to a pontifical vicar. In 1381, however, the bishop, Gabriele Gabrielli, succeeded in being appointed pontifical vicar and again, lord of Gubbio. Other bishops of Gubbio were • Rudolph
Gabrielli (1061), honoured for his sanctity by
Peter Damian; •
Alessandro Sperelli (1644), author of many learned works, who restored the cathedral.
Schism of 1159–1179 The bishopric of Theobaldus Balbi, O.S.B. (1160–1179) was unfortunately a time of great upheaval in the Church. The papal conclave of September 1159 had produced two popes, and a schism. The majority of cardinals elected Cardinal Rolando Bandinelli, who called himself
Pope Alexander III; a minority stood by Cardinal Octavianus de' Monticelli, who called himself
Pope Victor IV. Victor was a friend and adherent of the Emperor
Frederick Barbarossa. While Bishop Theobaldus professed obedience to Pope Alexander, Frederick appointed as Bishop of Gubbio the Abbot of the monastery of S. Donnato, Abbot Bonactus (Bonnato). The schism thus enveloped the diocese of Gubbio. A grant to the Church of Gubbio by the Emperor Frederick, dated 8 November 1163, indicates that the Ghibellines were in full control of the city and that Bonactus was bishop-elect. Bishop Theobaldus had retreated to the monastery of Fonte Avellina, where he had been Prior before his election as bishop; there he remained until the death of the intruder Bonactus, in 1164 or 1165. The schismatic Pope Victor IV died on 20 April 1164, and his schismatic successor Guido Cremensis (
Antipope Paschal III) died on 20 September 1168. Their successor, Joannes de Struma (
Calixtus III), surrendered to the real Pope, Alexander III, on 29 August 1178. The remnants of the schism were liquidated at the
Third Council of the Lateran in March 1179, by which time Bishop Theobaldus had died.
Suffragan From time immemorial, the bishops of Gubbio had been directly subordinate (suffragans) of the Holy See (Papacy), with no supervisory archbishop intervening, and were therefore required to attend Roman synods. But in 1563 the situation was altered. In his bull
Super universas of 4 June 1563, Pope Pius IV reorganized the administration of the territories of the March of Ancona by creating a new archbishopric by elevating the bishop and
Archdiocese of Urbino. He created the new ecclesiastical province of Urbino, which was to include the dioceses of Cagli, Pesaro, Fossombrone, Montefeltro, Senigallia. and Gubbio. But, as a result of the resistance begun by Bishop
Mariano Savelli, it was not until the eighteenth century that Urbino could exercise effective metropolitan jurisdiction. In the 15th century, the dukedoms of Montefeltro and Urbino fell into the hands of the della Rovere family. But the family did not prosper, in terms of male heirs. In 1623, the aged duke,
Francesco Maria II lost his only son to an epileptic seizure. Without suitable collateral relatives, he determined to leave his dukedoms to the Papacy, and, on 30 April 1624, the appropriate documents were registered in Rome. Taddeo Barberini, the nephew of
Pope Urban VIII, took formal possession and appointed a governor, though Duke Francesco Maria continued to rule during his lifetime. When he died on 23 April 1631, Urbino, and Gubbio along with it, was incorporated into the Papal States. In accordance with the decree
Christus Dominus, chapter 40, of the
Second Vatican Council, on 15 August 1972
Pope Paul VI issued the decree
Animorum utilitate, in which he changed the status of the diocese of Perugia, from being directly dependent upon the Holy See to being a Metropolitan archdiocese. The ecclesiastical province of Perugia was to contain as
suffragans the dioceses of Assisi, Citta di Castello, Citta della Pieve, Foligno, Nocera and Tadinum, and Gubbio. The diocese of Gubbio ceased to be dependent upon the archdiocese of Urbino.
Synods A diocesan synod was an irregularly held, but important, meeting of the bishop of a diocese and his clergy. Its purpose was (1) to proclaim generally the various decrees already issued by the bishop; (2) to discuss and ratify measures on which the bishop chose to consult with his clergy; (3) to publish statutes and decrees of the diocesan synod, of the provincial synod, and of the Holy See. Bishop Alessandro Sperelli (1644–1672) presided over seven diocesan synods; one was held on 10—12 July 1646, and another on 7—9 June 1650. Bishop Sostegno Maria Cavalli (1725–1747) held a diocesan synod in Gubbio in 1725; he held another on 13—15 September 1728. Bishop Vincenzo Massi (1821–1839) held a diocesan synod on 5—7 June 1827. ==Bishops of Gubbio==