At the time of its release,
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde received mostly positive reviews.
Entertainment Weekly James Bernard called the album a "freewheeling hip-hop cabaret", commending it for being humorous.
The Source Brett Johnson saw the Pharcyde as a combination of the "off-beat charm" of De La Soul and the "intense enthusiasm and energy" of
Leaders of the New School. He commended the instrumentals, which he described as a blend of "soulful pianos and organs" with "head-nodding basslines", as well as the group's vocal performance, but also thought the group might struggle to gain acceptance among the hardcore hip-hop audience. "The question many will have to answer for themselves is whether a trip to the Pharcyde is a step backwards or a leap into the future?", concluded the writer.
NME thought the Pharcyde created "their own sonic Utopia, a world that's by turns riotously funny, twisted, mostly right-on and brooding with noir-ish cool". The magazine placed
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde at number 39 on their 1993 year-end list of best albums, calling it a "cartoon-strip of blunt-smoking antics, sexual innuendo and unashamed political incorrectness, crammed with infectious funky beats".
Charles Aaron, in his review for
Spin, named
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde "one of the most musically vivid hip-hop records of the year", but added that "it's hard to hype a group so confused amused about itself".
Rolling Stone placed the album on their list of the best recordings on 1993, calling it a "fusion of punchy rhythm and loopy rhyme".
Retrospective In the years since its release, numerous publications have recognized
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde as a hip-hop classic.
AllMusic's John Bush hailed the album for the "amazing rapping and gifted productions", "easily some of the tightest and most inventive of any hip-hop record of the era", but thought it might be challenging for new listeners due to a lack of catchy elements.
Colin Larkin described it as a "multi-layered comic masterpiece" in
The Encyclopedia of Popular Music. Ross Scarano, in his review for
Pitchfork, called it "one of the most boisterous and creative acts of adolescent knuckleheadedness and confession in hip-hop history". Comparing it to other contemporaneous
West Coast hip-hop albums, he called
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde "fearlessly quotidian and relatively low-stakes", adding that the group used humor to deal with anxiety and pain.
RapReviews Jordan Selbo thought the group employs "style and a viewpoint deliciously and profoundly contradictory", "[s]imultaneously subtle and brazen, overtly celebratory yet deeply dark and twisted, both ephemeral and timeless in scope". He viewed
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde as a historic document that captures the experience of Black people in the US. Paul Bowler of
Record Collector praised the album for its uniqueness, for being "a rare but joyous example of rap without ego". Various publications placed
Bizarre Ride II the Pharcyde on their best-of lists.
Rolling Stone added it to the 2020 edition of their
The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list. It was featured in the 2005 book
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die, in which its author Robert Dimery called it "a true classic", commending the trio for "keep[ing] it original" and J-Swift for bringing "greater depth and a lush, soulful sound".
Accolades (*) designates lists which are unordered. ==Legacy==