According to
Entertainment Weekly editor David Browne, the album title is a nod to their two musical sides:
Black (as in the
R&B inflections of their upbeat tracks) and
Blue (their inclination toward mushy crooning). It also represented
Lou Pearlman's abuse and bruises. Browne wrote that "
The Call" (a
dance-pop song) "tells how to cheat on your mate by telling her your cell phone battery's low!, but it also has the blowsy feel of a rejected show tune".
Rolling Stones Barry Walters called it "the album's most frenzied cut". The second track "
Shape of My Heart" was described by Browne as a "predictable ballad", while
AllMusic's editor
Stephen Thomas Erlewine wrote that "the song flows as gracefully as '
I Want It That Way', prove that the Backstreet Boys do teen pop ballads better than anyone." The third track "
Get Another Boyfriend" uses "drama-crazed harmonies" and was described by Walters as "the album's most frenzied cut". Erlewine wrote that the track is a "dead ringer for '
It's Gonna Be Me' crossed with '
Baby One More Time'". Walters wrote that "not even R&B kingpin
Rodney "Darkchild" Jerkins can erase the Scandinavian sparkle from the fourth track "Shining Star". Walters wrote the sixth track, "The Answer to Our Life," which "bounces along on a perky melody inspired by their Swedish mentors." The seventh track, "Everyone," celebrates themselves and the power of their audience. Browne wrote that the song is "a clunky foot stomper, which continues the self-congratulatory tradition of their earlier '
We've Got It Goin' On' and '
Larger than Life.'" The eighth track, the ballad "
More than That", was praised by critics.
Entertainment Weekly praised "the graceful way their voices blend on the chorus," while
Rolling Stone praised "the symphonic splendor of the track." The ninth track, "Time," was written by the band members. Browne called it "piffle," while Walters said that it "could've sprung from any substandard
Nashville jingle meister." The tenth track, "Not for Me," received positive reviews. Browne praised "the spunky way they vault into the track." Browne wrote that "Time" & the 11th track "Yes I Will" appeared to be vying in a contest for "Next Big Wedding Song," but still acknowledged "the suave manner in which they engage in their trademark vocal swapping track" on the latter song. The 12th track, "It's True," is another ballad in the same vein as the others, while the last track, "How Did I Fall in Love with You," is sung by Howie D and Brian Littrell while the rest of the group does background. ==Critical reception==