Scoring and structure Bach structured the cantata in six movements. The first and last are set for choir, while the inner movements are set for soloists, in a sequence of aria – chorale – recitative – aria. Bach scored the work for four vocal soloists (
soprano (S),
alto (A),
tenor (T) and
bass (B)), a
four-part choir, and a
Baroque instrumental ensemble: two
oboes (Ob),
oboe da caccia (Oc), two
violins (Vl),
viola (Va),
violoncello piccolo (Vp) and
basso continuo (Bc). The duration of the piece was stated as 26 minutes by Bach scholar
Alfred Dürr but some currently available recordings last about 20 minutes. In the following table of the movements, the scoring follows the
Neue Bach-Ausgabe. The
keys and
time signatures are taken from Dürr's book about the cantatas, using the symbol for common time (4/4). The instruments are shown separately for winds and strings, while the continuo, playing throughout, is not shown.
Movements 1 The cantata opens with "" (Abide with us; for it is toward evening), a large-scale tripartite chorus, reminiscent of a slow
sarabande or of the closing
Ruht wohl, ihr heiligen Gebeine of the
St John Passion. The instruments, a choir of three oboes and strings, present a theme which Dürr describes as "of speech-like gestures". It is picked up by the voices, first in
homophony. The vocal lines in this movement descend on "" (for evening is nigh) "as if the gloom of night were weighing upon them". While the beginning of the movement has no tempo marking, the middle section is marked
Andante and in Alla-breve time, suggesting a faster pace. The voices, accompanied first only by the continuo, perform a
fugue on two subjects at the same time: "" (for it is toward evening) and "" (and the day is far spent). A third
motif, long notes on the same pitch, illustrates the "abiding" or staying. The movement is closed by a shortened reprise of the beginning. The Bach scholar
Klaus Hofmann compares the slow-fast-slow structure of the movement to the
French overture and notes that it opens a new series of cantatas. '' by Caravaggio
John Eliot Gardiner, who conducted the
Bach Cantata Pilgrimage in 2000, also noted the similarity to the last chorus,
Ruht wohl, from the St John Passion, describing the cantata's "tender pleadings which become ever more gestural and urgent for enlightenment in a darkening world from which Jesus' presence has been removed." He notes that while descending
motifs and
modulations illustrate the emotions of insecurity when left alone in the dark, Bach "introduces a counter-balance" of remaining steadfast, "by threading 25 Gs then 35 B-flats played in unison by violins and violas through the surrounding dissonance" and by repeated pleas to Jesus to remain sung on one note during the fugue. Gardiner was reminded of a similar stark contrast of light and darkness in the painting
Supper at Emmaus by Caravaggio.
2 The second movement, "" (Highly praised Son of God), is a
da capo aria for the alto, accompanied by an
obbligato oboe da caccia, which was replaced by viola in later performances. Dürr describes the choice of voice and obbligato in the same range as unusual and "of special charme". The opening phrase is illustrated by an upward line, while the mention of falling darkness is interpreted by downward
whole-tone steps.
3 The third movement, "" (Ah remain with us, Lord Jesus Christ), is a setting of the chorale with a virtuoso part for violincello piccolo, while the two stanzas are sung by the soprano only. This movement was later adapted as one of the
Schübler Chorales, BWV 649.
4 The only recitative is for bass, "" (The darkness has taken over in many places). Its "threatening chromatic bass line" reminds the listeners of "the gravity of the situation".
5 The last aria, "" (Jesus, let us look upon You), is for tenor with string accompaniment. The four notes for the name Jesu are a
cross motif. The movement is characterised by a persistent walking rhythm, somewhat mitigated by the flowing triplets in the violin line. Hofmann notes that the lively violin figures illustrate from the start the text about the "light of the Word of God shining more brightly", which appears only in the second part.
6 The four-part closing chorale, "" (Reveal Your strength, Lord Jesus Christ,), chorale is "quarried very little for musical building blocks", according to Julian Mincham, ending the work on a sombre tone. == Recordings ==