The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "Assessment of
Yield to the Night can only be made on two levels, those of the film itself: the study of a young woman awaiting execution for murder; and the novelettish flashbacks full of rejected and unfaithful lovers, etc. With this latter material we are in familiar screen territory – extensive London location shooting, a flashy camera style, wafer-thin characterisation and improbable motivation. On the film's other level a definite attempt has been made, in the writing and presentation, objectively to penetrate the condemned cell and the doomed psychology of the murderess. As a plea against capital punishment, however, the producers' conception of their drama seems to lack passion, and this makes it difficult to assimilate the film's emotional climate. Diana Dors, her natural exuberance muted, plays Mary Hilton touchingly, evoking gradual but positive sympathy."
Variety called it "a grim form of entertainment."
Filmink called it "a masterpiece, a stunningly good drama, where Dors plays a character who never asks for sympathy but gets it anyway: she's guilty of the crime, isn’t friendly to her family or death penalty protestors, still loves the louse who drove her to murder. The movie is full of little touches that speak volumes for Henry's personal experience in prison – the routine of changing guards, the conversations, the way the seconds drag on by, the visiting officials, the small privileges, the overwhelming pressure of the longing for a reprieve – and the final moments are devastating: it's one of the best British movies of the decade."
Leslie Halliwell said: "Gloomy prison melodrama vaguely based on the Ruth Ellis case and making an emotional plea against capital punishment." In
British Sound Films: The Studio Years 1928–1959 David Quinlan rated the film as "good", writing: "Convincing, if unrelievedly grim drama that proved its glamorous leading lady really could act."
The Radio Times Guide to Films gave the film 3/5 stars, writing: "Directed with a grim sense of purpose by J Lee Thompson, this sincere plea for the abolition of capital punishment was based on the case of Ruth Ellis, the last woman in Britain to be hanged and whose story was retold some 30 years later with a good deal more style by
Mike Newell in
Dance with a Stranger. Diana Dors gives one of the best performances of her career as the murderess recalling the circumstances that drove her to kill while waiting to hear if she will be reprieved." ==Accolades==