The dress was met with mixed reception. According to
Grazia Isabelle Truman, "thousands of people worldwide" praised Styles for challenging
toxic masculinity and
gender roles, emulating other musicians such as
David Bowie,
Freddie Mercury,
Elton John, and
Prince. Jireh Deng from
NPR similarly thought that while Styles's "stylistic and artistic freedom" was worthy of praise, it was a privilege not typically granted to individuals in the LGBTQ community. Several
conservative political commentators criticised the outfit for defying gendered fashion standards.
Ben Shapiro said it was "a referendum on masculinity for men to wear floofy dresses", and
Piers Morgan on
Good Morning Britain called the dress "a bit weird" and asked, "why do men need to wear dresses?" In a
tweet, commentator
Candace Owens called the dress an "outright attack" on society and demanded to "bring back manly men." Styles later shared an image of himself eating a banana and wearing a baby blue suit with a ruffled blouse, accompanied by the caption "bring back manly men", referencing Owens's tweet. Several
progressive public figures defended Styles following the conservative criticism, including politician
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, actress
Olivia Wilde, activist
Jameela Jamil, and actor
Elijah Wood. In an interview in October2021, Porter offered a more scathing critique of Styles and the cover: "He doesn't care, he's just doing it because it's the thing to do. This is politics for me. This is my life. [...] All he has to do is be white and straight." He later apologized for centering Styles in the conversation. == Legacy ==