American Idol DeGarmo took part in the third season of
American Idol in 2004, finishing second to winner
Fantasia Barrino. She was 16 years old at the time she competed. During her run on
American Idol she was thrice in the bottom three, but was the first contestant sent to safety each time and thus never in the bottom two. She became one of the front-runners by week 6. She performed around the country with the other third-season top-ten contestants during the summer of 2004.
Performances Post-Idol music tour|thumb|left DeGarmo was signed to RCA Records shortly after the
Idol finale and released her single, "
Dreams," on June 29, 2004. The single reached number 2 in Canada and number 14 on the
Billboard Hot 100 chart. The single also included her version of "
I Believe" and a remake of
Melissa Manchester's "Don't Cry Out Loud". She recorded her debut album in between
Idol summer tour stops. DeGarmo's debut album,
Blue Skies, was released on December 7, 2004, to opening week sales of 47,000. The album debuted at number 52 on the
Billboard 200 and included songs written by future American Idol judge
Kara DioGuardi, as well as
Desmond Child, Adam Shankman, and Andreas Carlsson, among others. As of fall 2008, the album had sold 168,000 copies with little to no advertising. The lone single from the CD, "Emotional", was released to radio in November 2004, peaking at number 54 on the
Mediabase Pop Chart. She toured independently in the spring and summer of 2005 in support of
Blue Skies. During the same time she recorded a song for the soundtrack of the
Disney movie
Ice Princess. "Reaching for Heaven", written by Desmond Child, can be heard during the climactic ice skating scene in the movie. In June 2005, RCA and DeGarmo parted ways. On September 17, 2005, DeGarmo received the Horizon Award at the Georgia Music Hall Of Fame Awards ceremony; the award recognizes Georgia artists on the path to successful and lengthy careers. DeGarmo began recording a pop/R&B album in 2007; however, she backed out of the project to return to her country music roots. After filming
CMT's
Gone Country in late 2007, she relocated to Nashville. She signed to John Rich's production company and recorded material with him in 2008. The songs were never released and DeGarmo moved on to other collaborators. In February 2009 she self-released a four-song acoustic country EP,
Unplugged in Nashville, to digital retailers. In March 2012, DeGarmo wrote "Good Goodbye" for use with her character on
The Young and the Restless. It was released to iTunes and was included on her May 2012 EP
Live to Love. After producing a music video for "Good Goodbye," fans were asked to vote on two versions of the video on the
American Idol website. DeGarmo presented and streamed a live concert of
Gemini in the summer of 2020, ultimately winning the 2020 BroadwayWorld Award for Best Streamed Concert.
Musical theatre DeGarmo made her major stage debut as Maria in an
American Musical Theatre of San Jose production of
West Side Story in November 2005. She followed with her Broadway debut in a four-month run of
Hairspray as nerdy
Penny Pingleton taking over for Tracy Miller in February 2006. She also performed the lead role of Brooklyn in the 2006 national tour of
Brooklyn: The Musical alongside one of her idols,
Melba Moore. DeGarmo returned to
Hairspray for a second engagement from September 2006 to February 2007. She made her
Carnegie Hall debut in April 2007 at a tribute to Neil Sedaka. In 2008, DeGarmo was set to star in a Broadway revival of
Godspell at the
Ethel Barrymore Theatre, but on August 19, it was announced that the show was postponed indefinitely due to the loss of an investor. In May 2009, DeGarmo starred in the musical revue
Back to Bacharach and David, which featured the songs of
Burt Bacharach and
Hal David. The
Kathy Najimy created and produced show played a limited two-week engagement in Los Angeles at the Music Box Theater on Hollywood Boulevard. In July 2009, she starred as the narrator in the Oklahoma Lyric's Theatre production of
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat alongside
Idol alum
Anthony Federov. Her next role saw her return to New York City when she debuted in August 2009 as Sarah, the "sexy, blind librarian" and love interest of Toxie, in the off-Broadway musical
The Toxic Avenger. The show was housed at New World Stages. DeGarmo remained with
Avenger until it closed on January 3, 2010. DeGarmo made her return to Broadway, starring as Sheila in the Broadway company of
Hair where she met her future husband, Ace Young. She succeeded original cast member
Caissie Levy beginning March 9, 2010. She played Sheila until the show's closure on June 27, 2010. DeGarmo played the role of Doralee Rhodes in the national tour of
9 to 5, which was launched in
Nashville on September 21, 2010. She ended her run as Doralee after the July 2011 Minneapolis tour stop. DeGarmo appeared on musical theatre composer Scott Alan's third album,
What I Wanna Be When I Grow Up with the song "I Wish", released November 1, 2010. She reprised the role of Penny Pingleton in the
Hollywood Bowl production of
Hairspray, which ran from August 5–7, 2011. DeGarmo has done several readings for new musicals over the years, starting with
In Your Dreams in early October 2006. In 2009, she played the title role in a concert for
Liberty: A New Musical at the New York Musical Theatre Festival (NYMF) and in 2009 played the role of
Chris in the much anticipated reading of an updated
Carrie: The Musical. In 2011 and again in 2013 she played Fern/Vylette in Manhattan industry readings of "Jawbreaker," a musical based on the 1990s movie of the same name. In January 2013, DeGarmo played "Sally" in the pre-Broadway run of the new musical "NERDS," in Raleigh, NC, for the North Carolina Theatre. DeGarmo played The Narrator in the national tour of
Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat from March 4, 2014, to April 2015. In June 2015, DeGarmo starred as Dorothy in Studio Tenn's production of
The Wizard of Oz at The Schermerhorn Symphony Theater in Nashville, Tennessee. She played Lucy in the 2016 to 2017 world tour of
Jekyll & Hyde. In 2023, she played the Witch in a regional production of
Into the Woods. In 2024, she returned to the regional stage as Audrey in
Little Shop of Horrors.
Film and television In 2006, DeGarmo was the singing voice of Cosmo on the "Fairy Idol" episode of
The Fairly OddParents. DeGarmo joined the cast of
The Young and the Restless in October 2011. She portrayed
Angelina Veneziano, the daughter of resident mobster,
Angelo. Her character was a terrible singer who was obsessed with gaining the affections of
Kevin Fisher. Her character went through a redemption arc, and by the time her last episode aired in March 2012, Angelina not only could sing, she had matured into a kinder and gentler character. In film, DeGarmo played
Dora Hand, a dance hall singer in the 2012
western film ''Wyatt Earp's Revenge.'' DeGarmo made a cameo appearance as herself in the Lifetime Network holiday movie
All About Christmas Eve starring
Haylie Duff. She also appeared on the second season of TLC's wedding dress show
Brides of Beverly Hills, which documented her search for a wedding dress. During 2013, DeGarmo and Ace Young hosted a weekly one-hour entertainment show,
Planet 360. It started on the Hallmark Movie Channel in March, moved to TVGN in May and was canceled in December. In 2013, DeGarmo starred in an independent film comedy,
Alto. DeGarmo's character, Frankie, is a struggling musician who falls in love with the daughter of a mafia don, and the two women become involved in a murder while also trying to come out to "Family." As of June 2015 the film has been shown at four festivals: The Miami Gay and Lesbian Film Festival, The VisionFest Film Festival in New York City, the
Hoboken International Film Festival in Middletown, New York and the Frameline LGBTQ film festival in San Francisco. DeGarmo was nominated for the Jack Nance Breakthrough Performance Award at VisionFest, where Alto won the Audience Award. In 2016, DeGarmo's third film,
The Morning Sun, based on the play
The Morning the Sun Fell Down, was released.
Charities DeGarmo is a celebrity ambassador of the Muscular Dystrophy Association, and supports the cause at events including the 2012 MDA "Show of Strength" Telethon to raise money for children and adults with neuromuscular disease. She also supports and performs in fundraisers for a number of charitable organizations both nationally and locally, including Broadway Cares/Equity Fights Aids.
Other activities DeGarmo was the first
American Idol finalist to participate in a USO tour. She has been on four USO tours overseas: • From December 2005 through January 2006 she entertained troops in Southwest Asia on a tour hosted by General
Peter Pace. Her song "Thank You" is inspired by this trip. • In April 2012, she and Ace Young toured, accompanied by fellow performers and athletes Anthony Anderson, Weeman, Dennis Haysbert, Randy Johnson, and The Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders. • In February 2013 she toured with Ace Young, Peyton Manning, Austin Collie, Curt Schilling and the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders. • In March 2015, DeGarmo, Andrew Luck, Weeman, Miss America, and several other celebrities toured the Middle East and military installations in Korea, Japan, and Hawaii. In late 2007/early 2008, DeGarmo participated as a Southern celebrity in television ads for the
Zaxby's restaurant chain. ==Personal life==