The Boondocks received critical acclaim and has earned several accolades. The first season garnered a score of 72 out of 100 on
Metacritic based on 21 reviews and a 59% approval rating on
Rotten Tomatoes based on 17 reviews, with an average rating of 8.10/10. Several websites listed
The Boondocks as one of the greatest animated series of all time. In January 2006, it was nominated for Outstanding Comedy Series at the 37th
NAACP Image Awards alongside
The Bernie Mac Show,
Everybody Hates Chris,
Girlfriends, and
Half & Half. The show won a
Special Honorary Academy Award of Merit in 2006 for the episode "Return of the King", which recognized George Foster Peabody as the Breakout Visionary Achievement In Excellence, For The Most Historic Landmark-In-Crowning-Achievement Milestone In History.
IGN named it the 94th-best animated series, describing it as a sharp satirical look at American society. Mike Hale of the
New York Times has considered
The Boondocks among the top television shows of 2010, citing "Pause" as a "painfully funny" satire of Tyler Perry being portrayed as a superstar actor and a leader of a homoerotic cult. In 2013, IGN placed
The Boondocks as number 17 on their list of Top 25 animated series for adults.
Criticism and controversy The Boondocks has been a frequent subject of controversy since its comic-strip debut in 1999, with
ABC News noting, "Fans and critics of
The Boondocks loved and hated the strip for the same reasons: its cutting-edge humor and unapologetic, sometimes unpopular, views on various issues, including race, politics, the
war on terrorism and the
September 11 attacks." Numerous outlets predicted the show would encounter controversy prior to its November 2005 debut, due to its casual use of the word "nigga". In 2006, the Reverend
Al Sharpton protested the first-season episode "
Return of the King", for
Martin Luther King Jr.'s character's use of the word "nigga", saying "
Cartoon Network must apologize and also commit to pulling episodes that desecrate black historic figures." Cartoon Network released a statement in response defending McGruder: "We think Aaron McGruder came up with a thought-provoking way of not only showing Dr. King's bravery but also of reminding us of what he stood and fought for, and why even today, it is important for all of us to remember that and to continue to take action," the statement said. The episode was later awarded a
Peabody Award for being "an especially daring episode". During Season 2, two episodes were removed from broadcast without any official word from the network. Originally slated to air on November 16 and December 17,
Tyler Perry was reportedly infuriated by his depiction in the season 3 episode "
Pause", first aired in June 2010, although he has officially given no response. The episode stars Winston Jerome, a parody of Perry, a "closeted, cross-dressing cult leader whose love of the Christian faith is a mask for his true sexuality," in what the
Los Angeles Times described as "one of the sharpest public criticisms of Perry". Soon after the episode aired, Perry got in touch with executives at
Turner Broadcasting and "complained loudly" about the episode, threatening to rethink his relationship with the company. In 2010,
Time magazine named
The Boondocks as fifth out of
10 of the Most Controversial Cartoons of All Time. In June 2020, when the initial run of
The Boondocks was uploaded to HBO Max, the Season 3 episode "The Story of Jimmy Rebel" was intentionally excluded due to perceived racial insensitivities over the episode's portrayal of a racist
country singer named Jimmy Rebel (a parody of real-life
white supremacist country singer
Johnny Rebel). Upon being asked for comment, an Adult Swim representative stated that "When Adult Swim transitions series to a new platform we determine what episodes are selected through creative and cultural filters and our standards and practices policies. Oftentimes these decisions are made in collaboration with the show's creator". Episodes of
Aqua Teen Hunger Force and
The Shivering Truth were also excluded from the service for similar reasons. == Revival attempts ==