While The Posies were on hiatus, Young joined
Adam Schlesinger and
Chris Collingwood and formed Fountains of Wayne. Their first self-titled album tied for second place in the Billboard magazine's 1996 Critics' Poll and their single "
Radiation Vibe" hit number 14 on the Billboard Modern Rock Tracks in 1997. In 2021, “Radiation Vibe” placed #380 in
Rolling Stone’s updated list of the 500 best songs of all time. After recording and touring for The Posies fifth album,
Success (1998), Young recorded with Fountains of Wayne on their second album
Utopia Parkway (1999). In 2003 the band released
Welcome Interstate Managers, which featured the single "
Stacy's Mom," a song that reached #3 on the Billboard Top 40 Mainstream Chart and earned a gold record. The video of “Stacy’s Mom” featured model
Rachel Hunter was in heavy high rotation MTV.
Welcome Interstate Managers reached #115 on the Billboard Top 200. The song “All Kinds of Time,” about a football star, was used to promote the 2005
NFL season. Young went on to record three more albums with Fountains of Wayne, 2007’s
Traffic and Weather, which reached number 97 on the Billboard Top 200 charts, and 2011’s
Sky Full of Holes. He also played on the band’s double disc collection of unreleased material and fan favorites, 2005’s
Out-of-State Plates. Voted the #3 best alternative rock drummer in the DRUM! Magazine 2006 Readers’ Poll, Young is known for his versatile drumming style. In a 2007 profile in Modern Drummer, Young said, “The cool thing about Fountains of Wayne is that we do a whole lot of different stylistic stuff.” In that same interview, Young said he was influenced by “the great studio drummers of the 1970s and to some degree, every musician that I’ve ever heard or seen.” ==Post-Fountains work==