After proposals for the dam surfaced, they met with almost immediate opposition from environmental groups such as the
Sierra Club, as well as an outcry from recreation-minded general public. The reason for this was because the dam would back water up for along the border of Grand Canyon National Park, and through
Grand Canyon National Monument. The resistance was strengthened by previous controversies relating to the encroachment of dams and reservoirs on protected lands, most notably
O'Shaughnessy Dam, built in
Yosemite National Park in 1924; the
Glen Canyon Dam, completed in 1966, and the earlier controversy over the U.S. of Bureau of Reclamation's proposed
Echo Park Dam, which would have flooded sections of Utah's
Dinosaur National Monument. All of the proposals thus far for the dam had failed for one reason or another. In 1938, the state of Arizona attempted to gain federal permission to build the dam. Even though the hypothetical dam and its reservoir lie along a remote, seldom seen or visited reach of the Colorado River, it would still destroy many well-known landmarks and points of interest. These include lower
Havasu Creek, famed for its travertine formations and waterfalls, and
Lava Falls, one of the most spectacular rapids on the Colorado. Opponents stated that the relatively low storage capacity of the dam, as well as its potential to evaporate more than of water per year, do not justify the dam's destruction of natural features and disruption to river ecology and recreational activities. Because of the heavy silt load of the Colorado, Bridge Canyon Reservoir would eventually fill with sediment, rendering it useless. Estimates by the Sierra Club suggested a useful life span of 60–160 years, while the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation predicts 163 years. The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation suggested building additional dams on Kanab Creek, the
Little Colorado River and
Paria River to act as silt traps in order to prolong the life span up to 250 years. The completion of
Glen Canyon Dam upstream in 1966 effectively reduced the flow of sediment through the Grand Canyon by 85 percent, extending the Bridge Canyon project life indefinitely. However, this alone was not enough to save the dam. As a result, the Bridge Canyon project officially stalled in 1984. The Pacific Southwest Water Plan was eventually implemented on a limited scale and is now known as the
Central Arizona Project.{{cite web ==Works cited==