No consensus has been reached as to the taxonomic position of
Chaetomys. It is commonly placed with the New World porcupines in the family
Erethizontidae or with the spiny rats the family
Echimyidae. Both are
South American
hystricognaths with hairs modified as spines or quills.
Chaetomys has more highly developed spines than the spiny rats, but less developed than the porcupines. Characteristics of the
premolar suggest that it belongs with the Echimyidae, but characteristics of the
incisor enamel suggest that it belongs in the Erethizontidae. Patterson and Pascual (1968), Patterson and Wood (1982), Woods (1982, 1984, 1993) Patton and Reig (1989), Nowak (1999), and Carvalho (2000) support the inclusion of this animal in Echimyidae whereas Martin (1994), McKenna and Bell (1997), Carvalho and Salles (2004), and Woods and Kilpatrick (2005) argue that it belongs in Erethizontidae. Emmons (2005) mentions the family Chaetomyidae without much further comment except to exclude it from Echimyidae. A molecular
phylogeny based on the
mitochondrial gene coding for
cytochrome b combined to
karyological evidence actually suggests that
Chaetomys is more closely related to the Erethizontidae than to the Echimyidae, although it branches as the sister group to the rest of the Erethizontidae. == References ==