Broxburn reached the
Scottish Junior Cup semi-final on five occasions, the last time being in 1971 when they lost by a single goal to eventual cup winners
Cambuslang Rangers. The club won the
East Region South Division in 2009–10 and then gained promotion to the
East Superleague two years later. They spent six seasons in the Superleague, with a best finish of the 5th in their final season. After moving to the
senior football pyramid for the 2018–19 season, Broxburn won the East of Scotland League Conference C. However they narrowly missed out on the title and promotion to the Lowland league in the round robin playoff against the winners of the other Conferences,
Penicuik Athletic and
Bonnyrigg Rose. Broxburn were champions in the 2023–24 season, finishing in front of title race rivals
Musselburgh Athletic and once again earned the spot in the promotion playoffs where they faced
South of Scotland Football League champions
Dalbeattie Star F.C.. The first leg was played at Dalbeattie's Islecroft stadium, and the 2nd leg at Broxburn's Albyn park. Broxburn were victorious, securing a 12-2 aggregate victory and promotion to the
Lowland Football League for the 2024-25 season. The club became a full
SFA member in 2019 which allowed them to enter the
2019–20 Scottish Cup. They reached the fourth round having won five matches (including victories over higher ranked
East Stirlingshire,
Cowdenbeath, and
Inverurie Loco Works), before going out to Premiership side
St. Mirren in Paisley. Broxburn were supported by 1,600 fans who has made the trip along the M8, selling out the North Stand at
St Mirren Park. In the
2023–24 Scottish Cup Broxburn reached the third round after victories over
Lochee United,
Nairn County and
Deveronvale before going out on penalties to
Buckie Thistle at Albyn Park. The reported attendance of this match was 1175. ==Albyn Park==