Humphrey accepted a football scholarship from
Baylor University, along with Hickman. He was an All-Conference player at
quarterback. As a sophomore, he scored the winning
touchdown on a
quarterback sneak in Baylor's
1957 Sugar Bowl 13-7 victory, over the undefeated, highly-favored and No. 2-ranked
University of Tennessee. In 1958, he led the nation with 112 completions for 1,316 yards. In the season finale he passed for 387 yards and 5 touchdowns against
Rice University, which was a school record that stood until 2006. As a junior and senior, his teams finished last in the
Southwest Conference. At the conclusion of his senior season, he played in the December 1958
North–South Shrine Game, where he had 5 touchdown passes and was named MVP, and the January 1959
Senior Bowl, where he was a co-captain of the South team. In 2006, Humphrey was inducted into the Baylor Sports Hall of Fame. ==Professional career==