France In August 2009, a woman in
France was prevented from swimming in a public pool wearing a burkini, amidst
ongoing controversy about Muslim dress. The action was justified by reference to a law that forbids swimming in street clothes. The controversy over the burkini in France may also be seen as reflecting broadly held French attitudes against religious expression in public. French law emphasizes the importance of creating a "religiously neutral arena" in which people are expected to appear similar, as well as being treated equally. In this, France differs significantly from countries such as the United States, which emphasizes individual freedom of choice about whether to express religious sentiments. At least 20 other French towns, including
Nice, subsequently joined the ban. Following this, dozens of women were issued fines, with some tickets citing not wearing "an outfit respecting good morals and secularism"; furthermore, some women were verbally attacked by bystanders when they were confronted by the police. Enforcement of the ban also hit beachgoers wearing a wide range of modest attire besides the burkini, such as an ordinary long-sleeved shirt and
leggings worn over a typical swimsuit.
Reactions The ban was supported by a number of French politicians, including the socialist prime minister
Manuel Valls, who said: "The burkini is not a new range of swimwear, a fashion. It is the expression of a political project, a counter-society, based notably on the enslavement of women." Some commentators in France criticized the bans, and reports of Muslim women being stopped by police for wearing headscarves and long-sleeved clothes on beaches caused outrage among members of the French Socialist Party and rights groups. The bans and their enforcement prompted criticism and ridicule abroad, particularly in English-speaking countries. A
New York Times editorial called French politicians' "paternalistic pronouncements on the republic's duty to save Muslim women from enslavement" bigotry and hypocritical. Other Muslim commentators, particularly Muslim women, have argued that the burkini gives women who do not wish to expose their body for religious or other reasons the freedom to enjoy the beach.
Human Rights Watch also criticized the ban, stating that it "actually amounts to banning women from the beach, in the middle of the summer, just because they wish to cover their bodies in public. It's almost a form of collective punishment against Muslim women for the actions of others." Some drew parallels between the burkini ban and the French ban of the Catholic
soutane some 111 years earlier after the
1905 French law on the Separation of the Churches and the State.
Germany In December 2018, the municipality of
Koblenz, citing hygiene concerns, voted to ban the burkini in public swimming pools in 2018, with CDU, AfD and Freie Wähler councillors forming a majority for the decision. Protests were held against the decision gathering some 70 individuals from
Central Council of Muslims in Germany,
Social Democratic Party of Germany and
Alliance 90/The Greens. In June 2019, German courts overruled and lifted the ban citing violations to the German constitution's call for equality. In June 2018, a school in western Germany created controversy after it was found handing out burkinis to students who otherwise refused to attend swim classes. Some argued that the school is sending a misogynistic message, including Julia Klöckner, a member of Angela Merkel's Christian Democratic party, who said the school creates a "misogynistic understanding in a place where children and teenagers are supposed to learn the opposite." Others, including Franziska Giffey, the German minister of family affairs, support the school's decision saying, "the most important thing is the well-being of the children, and that means that all learn to swim."
Switzerland In December 2017, the Swiss city of
Geneva passed a law requiring swimmers to wear swimsuits that do not go lower than the knee and keep the swimmer's arms bare, which would effectively ban not only burkinis but also the
bodyskins used by elite swimmers,
swim dresses,
rash guards,
wetsuits, and other styles of swimsuits. They simultaneously banned
topless swimming in the city pools. The September rule was prompted by young people swimming in public pools in
street wear (e.g., ordinary T-shirts), which had caused concerns about hygiene. Before the ban, councillors were only aware of one person having ever worn a burkini to the city's pools. ==See also==