Rotten Tomatoes has cataloged three negative reviews and one positive. Ronnie Scheib of
Variety called it "an American
Vivre sa vie without the passion, drama or gorgeous imagery". Paul Brunick of
The New York Times wrote that Swanberg's biggest talent is his ability to get actresses to strip naked. Nick Pinkerton of
The Village Voice wrote, "It is possible that one of Swanberg’s movies is not a complete waste of time, but
Caitlin Plays Herself, written in collaboration with its starlet, Caitlin Stainkin, is not the one." Jaime N. Christley of
Slant Magazine rated it 3/4 stars and compared it to
Tsai Ming-liang's
What Time Is It There?. == References ==