Centaurea stoebe has been introduced to
North America, where it is considered an invasive species in much of the western US and Canada. In 2000,
C. stoebe occupied more than in the US. Spotted knapweed is a
pioneer species found in recently disturbed sites or openings, growing in dense stands.
History in North America , Douglas County, Washington Spotted knapweed likely spread to North America in an
alfalfa shipment. It was first recorded in
Bingen,
Klickitat County, Washington, in the late 1800s. By 1980, it had spread to 26 counties in the
Pacific Northwest. In the year 2000, it was reported in 45 of the 50 states of the US. It primarily affects rangelands of the northwest US and Canada. A 1996 study estimated its direct and secondary economic effects in Montana to be approximately $42 million annually. When it replaces native grasses, soil erosion and
surface runoff are increased, depleting precious soil resources. In 2015, a
Missoula, Montana, beekeeper whose bees rely on local knapweed stated that "knapweed produces great honey ... people should consider planting native wildflowers instead of just taking out weeds."
Catechin controversy The roots of
Centaurea stoebe exude (-)-
catechin, which has been proposed to function as a natural
herbicide that may inhibit competition by a wide range of other plant species. While this
phytotoxic compound can inhibit seed germination and growth at high concentrations, it is debated whether concentrations in field soils are high enough to affect competition with neighboring plants. Several high-profile papers arguing for the importance of catechin as an allelochemical were retracted after it was found that they contained fabricated data showing unnaturally high levels of catechin in soils surrounding
C. stoebe. Subsequent studies from the original lab have not been able to replicate the results from these retracted studies, nor have most independent studies conducted in other laboratories. Thus, it is doubtful whether the levels of (-)-catechin found in soils are high enough to affect competition with neighboring plants. The proposed mechanism of action (acidification of the cytoplasm through oxidative damage) has also been criticized, on the basis that (-)-catechin is actually an antioxidant.
Control An 8-year study in
Michigan found that restoring native plant communities in knapweed-infested sites requires multi-faceted and multi-year approaches. This includes an initial site preparation by mowing and an optional application of a
clopyralid or
glyphosate herbicide followed by reseeding with the desired plant communities. Yearly hand pulling of
C. stoebe over the course of the study virtually eradicated the infestation. Burning treatments of infested sites reduced the labour needs for pulling and encouraged native plant community establishment. Another study over 3 years comparing the effectiveness of different combinations of annual spring, summer, and fall mowing treatments recommends an annual fall mowing during the flowering or seed-production stage in controlling
C. stoebe infestations.
Biocontrol Thirteen
biological pest control agents have been used against this plant and its congener,
diffuse knapweed (
C. diffusa), including the
moths,
Agapeta zoegana and
Metzneria paucipunctella; the
weevils,
Bangasternus fausti,
Larinus obtusus,
Larinus minutus and
Cyphocleonus achates; and the
fruit flies,
Chaetorellia acrolophi,
Urophora affinis and
Urophora quadrifasciata. Although the number of seeds is significantly reduced, this is not enough to make biocontrol truly effective against
C. stoebe. She followed it up with 98% in the final trials in open fields, demonstrating that dogs can effectively detect low densities of invasive plants. ==Toxicity==