Russian Empire (1906–1910) In 1906, he moved to
Saint Petersburg, which was then the capital of the Russian Empire and the center of the country's artistic life, with famous art schools. Since Jews were not permitted into the city without an internal passport, he managed to get a temporary passport from a friend. He enrolled in a prestigious art school and studied there for two years. By 1907, he had begun painting naturalistic self-portraits and landscapes. Chagall was an active member of the irregular
freemasonic lodge, the
Grand Orient of Russia's Peoples. He belonged to the "Vitebsk" lodge. Between 1908 and 1910, Chagall was a student of
Léon Bakst at the Zvantseva School of Drawing and Painting. While in Saint Petersburg, he discovered experimental theater, and the work of such artists as
Paul Gauguin. Bakst, also Jewish, was a designer of decorative art and was famous as a draftsman designer of stage sets and costumes for the
Ballets Russes, and helped Chagall by acting as a role model for Jewish success. Bakst moved to Paris a year later. Art historian Raymond Cogniat writes that after living and studying art on his own for four years, "Chagall entered into the mainstream of contemporary art. ...His apprenticeship over, Russia had played a memorable initial role in his life." Chagall stayed in Saint Petersburg until 1910, often visiting Vitebsk where he met
Bella Rosenfeld. In
My Life, Chagall described his first meeting her: "Her silence is mine, her eyes mine. It is as if she knows everything about my childhood, my present, my future, as if she can see right through me." Bella later wrote, of meeting him, "When you did catch a glimpse of his eyes, they were as blue as if they'd fallen straight out of the sky. They were strange eyes … long, almond-shaped … and each seemed to sail along by itself, like a little boat."
France (1910–1914) '' In 1910, Chagall relocated to Paris to develop his artistic style. Art historian and curator James Sweeney notes that when Chagall first arrived in Paris, Cubism was the dominant art form, and French art was still dominated by the "materialistic outlook of the 19th century". But Chagall arrived from Russia with "a ripe color gift, a fresh, unashamed response to sentiment, a feeling for simple poetry and a sense of humor", he adds. These notions were alien to Paris at that time, and as a result, his first recognition came not from other painters but from poets such as
Blaise Cendrars and
Guillaume Apollinaire. Art historian
Jean Leymarie observes that Chagall began thinking of art as "emerging from the internal being outward, from the seen object to the psychic outpouring", which was the reverse of the Cubist way of creating. He therefore developed friendships with
Guillaume Apollinaire and other
avant-garde artists including
Robert Delaunay and
Fernand Léger. Baal-Teshuva writes that "Chagall's dream of Paris, the city of light and above all, of freedom, had come true." His first days were a hardship for the 23-year-old Chagall, who was lonely in the big city and unable to speak French. Some days he felt like fleeing back to Russia, as he daydreamed while he painted, about the riches of
Russian folklore, his
Hasidic experiences, his family, and especially Bella. In Paris, he enrolled at
Académie de La Palette, an
avant-garde school of art where the painters
Jean Metzinger,
André Dunoyer de Segonzac and
Henri Le Fauconnier taught, and also found work at another academy. He would spend his free hours visiting galleries and salons, especially the
Louvre; artists he came to admire included
Rembrandt, the
Le Nain brothers,
Chardin,
van Gogh,
Renoir,
Pissarro,
Matisse,
Gauguin,
Courbet,
Millet,
Manet,
Monet,
Delacroix, and others. It was in Paris that he learned the technique of
gouache, which he used to paint Russian scenes. He also visited
Montmartre and the
Latin Quarter "and was happy just breathing Parisian air". Baal-Teshuva describes this new phase in Chagall's artistic development: During his time in Paris, Chagall was constantly reminded of his home in
Vitebsk, as Paris was also home to many painters, writers, poets, composers, dancers, and other émigrés from the Russian Empire. However, "night after night he painted until dawn", only then going to bed for a few hours, and resisted the many temptations of the big city at night. "My homeland exists only in my soul", he once said. He continued painting Jewish motifs and subjects from his memories of Vitebsk, although he included Parisian scenes — the Eiffel Tower in particular, along with portraits. Many of his works were updated versions of paintings he had made in Russia, transposed into
Fauvist or
Cubist keys. Chagall developed a whole repertoire of quirky motifs: ghostly figures floating in the sky, ... the gigantic fiddler dancing on miniature dollhouses, the livestock and transparent wombs and, within them, tiny offspring sleeping upside down. The majority of his scenes of life in Vitebsk were painted while living in Paris, and "in a sense they were dreams", notes Lewis. Their "undertone of yearning and loss", with a detached and abstract appearance, caused Apollinaire to be "struck by this quality", calling them "surnaturel!" His "animal/human hybrids and airborne phantoms" would later become a formative influence on
Surrealism. Chagall, however, did not want his work to be associated with any school or movement and considered his own personal language of symbols to be meaningful to himself. But Sweeney notes that others often still associate his work with "illogical and fantastic painting", especially when he uses "curious representational juxtapositions". Sweeney writes that "This is Chagall's contribution to contemporary art: the reawakening of a poetry of representation, avoiding factual illustration on the one hand, and non-figurative abstractions on the other".
André Breton said that "with him alone, the metaphor made its triumphant return to modern painting".
Russia (1914–1922) Because he missed his fiancée, Bella, who was still in Vitebsk—"He thought about her day and night", writes Baal-Teshuva—and was afraid of losing her, Chagall decided to accept an invitation from a noted gallery owner in Berlin to exhibit his work, his intention being to continue on to Russia, marry Bella, and then return with her to Paris. Chagall took 40 canvases and 160 gouaches, watercolors and drawings to be exhibited. The exhibit, held at
Herwarth Walden's
Sturm Gallery was a huge success, "The German critics positively sang his praises." After the exhibit, he continued on to Vitebsk, where he planned to stay only long enough to marry Bella. However, after a few weeks, the First World War began, closing the Russian border for an indefinite period. A year later he married Bella Rosenfeld and they had their first child, Ida. During the war, Chagall worked for the
War Industry Committee in Petrograd, set up in 1915 to supply the
Imperial Russian Army. Before the marriage, Chagall had difficulty convincing Bella's parents that he would be a suitable husband for their daughter. They were worried about her marrying a painter from a poor family and wondered how he would support her. Becoming a successful artist now became a goal and inspiration. According to Lewis, "[T]he euphoric paintings of this time, which show the young couple floating balloon-like over Vitebsk—its wooden buildings faceted in the Delaunay manner—are the most lighthearted of his career". His wedding pictures were also a subject he would return to in later years as he thought about this period of his life. '', 1917 In 1915, Chagall began exhibiting his work in Moscow, first exhibiting his works at a well-known salon and in 1916 exhibiting pictures in St. Petersburg. He again showed his art at a Moscow exhibition of avant-garde artists. This exposure brought recognition, and a number of wealthy collectors began buying his art. He also began illustrating a number of Yiddish books with ink drawings. He illustrated
I. L. Peretz's
The Magician in 1917. Chagall was 30 years old and had begun to become well known. The
October Revolution of 1917 was a dangerous time for Chagall although it also offered opportunity. Chagall wrote he came to fear Bolshevik orders pinned on fences, writing: "The factories were stopping. The horizons opened. Space and emptiness. No more bread. The black lettering on the morning posters made me feel sick at heart". Chagall was often hungry for days, later remembering watching "a bride, the beggars and the poor wretches weighted down with bundles", leading him to conclude that the new regime had turned the Russian Empire "upside down the way I turn my pictures". By then he was one of Imperial Russia's most distinguished artists and a member of the
modernist avant-garde, which enjoyed special privileges and prestige as the "aesthetic arm of the revolution". In November 1917,
Anatoly Lunacharsky offered Chagall to be in charge of the visual arts department of
Narkompros in Petrograd. Chagall refused the offer, mostly due to his disinterest in politics. In the summer of 1918, however, Chagall questioned his refusal and went to visit Lunacharsky in Petrograd. Shortly afterwards the artist was appointed commissar of arts for Vitebsk. This resulted in his founding both the People's Art College, also known as "the Academy", and the Art Museum in Vitebsk. Under Chagall's leadership, the college attracted major artists such as
El Lissitzky and
Kazimir Malevich,, while the creation of the museum signified the so called "Vitebsk Renaissance" making the town one of the well-known avant-garde centers of the early 20th century. He also hired his first teacher,
Yehuda Pen, to work at the school. Chagall tried to create an atmosphere of a collective of independently minded artists, each with their own unique style. However, this would soon prove to be difficult as a few of the key faculty members preferred a Suprematist art of squares and circles, and disapproved of Chagall's attempt at creating "bourgeois individualism". In May 1920, the Academy was taken over by the suprematists, which led to Chagall's resignation and his departure for Moscow. When the suprematists themselves left the Academy, it declined, becoming an ordinary college of applied art. The avant-garde in Russia was then ousted by other artistic trends. In Moscow he was offered a job as stage designer for the newly formed State Jewish Chamber Theater. It was set to begin operation in early 1921 with a number of plays by
Sholem Aleichem. For its opening he created a number of large background murals using techniques he learned from Bakst, his early teacher. One of the main murals was tall by long and included images of various lively subjects such as dancers, fiddlers, acrobats, and farm animals. One critic at the time called it "Hebrew jazz in paint". Chagall created it as a "storehouse of symbols and devices", notes Lewis. The murals "constituted a landmark" in the history of the theatre, and were forerunners of his later large-scale works, including murals for the New York
Metropolitan Opera and the
Paris Opera. The
First World War ended in 1918, but the
Russian Civil War continued, and famine spread. The Chagalls found it necessary to move to a smaller, less expensive, town near Moscow, although Chagall now had to commute to Moscow daily, using crowded trains. In 1921, he worked as an art teacher along with his friend sculptor
Isaac Itkind in a Jewish boys' shelter in suburban
Malakhovka, which housed young refugees orphaned by pogroms. While there, he created a series of illustrations for the Yiddish poetry cycle
Grief written by
David Hofstein, who was another teacher at the Malakhovka shelter. After spending the years between 1921 and 1922 living in primitive conditions, he decided to go back to France so that he could develop his art in a more comfortable country. Numerous other artists, writers, and musicians were also planning to relocate to the West. He applied for an exit visa and while waiting for its uncertain approval, wrote his autobiography,
My Life.
France (1923–1941) , 1923 In 1923, Chagall left Moscow to return to France. On his way he stopped in Berlin to recover the many pictures he had left there on exhibit ten years earlier, before the war began, but was unable to find or recover any of them. Nonetheless, after returning to Paris he again "rediscovered the free expansion and fulfillment which were so essential to him", writes Lewis. With all his early works now lost, he began trying to paint from his memories of his earliest years in Vitebsk with sketches and oil paintings. He formed a business relationship with French art dealer
Ambroise Vollard. This inspired him to begin creating etchings for a series of illustrated books, including
Gogol's
Dead Souls, the Bible, and the ''
La Fontaine's Fables. These illustrations would eventually come to represent his finest printmaking efforts. In 1924, he travelled to Brittany and painted La fenêtre sur l'
Île-de-Bréhat. By 1926 he had his first exhibition in the United States at the Reinhardt gallery of New York which included about 100 works, although he did not travel to the opening. He instead stayed in France, "painting ceaselessly", notes Baal-Teshuva. It was not until 1927 that Chagall made his name in the French art world, when art critic and historian Maurice Raynal awarded him a place in his book Modern French Painters''. However, Raynal was still at a loss to accurately describe Chagall to his readers: During this period he traveled throughout France and the
Côte d'Azur, where he enjoyed the landscapes, colorful vegetation, the blue
Mediterranean Sea, and the mild weather. He made repeated trips to the countryside, taking his sketchbook. He also visited nearby countries and later wrote about the impressions some of those travels left on him:
The Bible illustrations After returning to Paris from one of his trips, Vollard commissioned Chagall to illustrate the
Old Testament. Although he could have completed the project in France, he used the assignment as an excuse to travel to
Mandatory Palestine to experience for himself the
Holy Land. In 1931 Marc Chagall and his family traveled to Tel Aviv on the invitation of
Meir Dizengoff. Dizengoff had previously encouraged Chagall to visit Tel Aviv in connection with Dizengoff's plan to build a Jewish Art Museum in the new city. Chagall and his family were invited to stay at Dizengoff's house in Tel Aviv, which later became Independence Hall of the
State of Israel. Chagall ended up staying in the Holy Land for two months. Chagall felt at home in Israel where many people spoke Yiddish and Russian. According to Jacob Baal-Teshuva, "he was impressed by the pioneering spirit of the people in the
kibbutzim and deeply moved by the
Wailing Wall and the other holy places". Chagall later told a friend that Palestine gave him "the most vivid impression he had ever received". Jackie Wullschlager notes, however, that whereas Delacroix and Matisse had found inspiration in the exoticism of North Africa, he as a Jew in Palestine had different perspective. "What he was really searching for there was not external stimulus but an inner authorization from the land of his ancestors, to plunge into his work on the Bible illustrations". Chagall stated that "In the East I found the Bible and part of my own being." As a result, he immersed himself in "the history of the Jews, their trials, prophecies, and disasters", notes Wullschlager. She adds that beginning the assignment was an "extraordinary risk" for Chagall, as he had finally become well known as a leading contemporary painter, but would now end his modernist themes and delve into "an ancient past". Between 1931 and 1934 he worked "obsessively" on "The Bible", even going to
Amsterdam in order to carefully study the biblical paintings of
Rembrandt and
El Greco, to see the extremes of religious painting. He walked the streets of the city's Jewish quarter to again feel the earlier atmosphere. He told Franz Meyer: Chagall saw the
Old Testament as a "human story, ... not with the creation of the cosmos but with the creation of man, and his figures of angels are rhymed or combined with human ones", writes Wullschlager. She points out that in one of his early Bible images, "Abraham and the Three Angels", the angels sit and chat over a glass of wine "as if they have just dropped by for dinner". He returned to France and by the next year had completed 32 out of the total of 105 plates. By 1939, at the beginning of World War II, he had finished 66. However, Vollard died that same year. When the series was completed in 1956, it was published by Edition
Tériade. Baal-Teshuva writes that "the illustrations were stunning and met with great acclaim. Once again Chagall had shown himself to be one of the 20th century's most important graphic artists". Leymarie has described these drawings by Chagall as "monumental" and,
Nazi campaigns against modern art Not long after Chagall began his work on the
Bible,
Adolf Hitler gained power in Germany. Anti-Semitic laws were being introduced and the first concentration camp at
Dachau had been established. Wullschlager describes the early effects on art: Beginning during 1937 about twenty thousand works from German museums were confiscated as "
degenerate" by a committee directed by
Joseph Goebbels. Although the German press had once "swooned over him", the new German authorities now made a mockery of Chagall's art, describing them as "green, purple, and red Jews shooting out of the earth, fiddling on violins, flying through the air ... representing [an] assault on Western civilization". After Germany invaded and occupied France, the Chagalls remained in
Vichy France, unaware that French Jews, with the help of the
Vichy government, were being collected and sent to German concentration camps, from which few would return. The Vichy collaborationist government, directed by Marshal
Philippe Pétain, immediately upon assuming power established a commission to "redefine French citizenship" with the aim of stripping "undesirables", including naturalized citizens, of their French nationality. Chagall had been so involved with his art, that it was not until October 1940, after the Vichy government, at the behest of the Nazi occupying forces, began approving anti-Semitic laws, that he began to understand what was happening. Learning that Jews were being removed from public and academic positions, the Chagalls finally "woke up to the danger they faced". But Wullschlager notes that "by then they were trapped". Their only refuge could be the US, but "they could not afford the passage to New York" or the large bond that each immigrant had to provide upon entry to ensure that they would not become a financial burden to the country.
Escaping occupied France According to Wullschlager, "[T]he speed with which France collapsed astonished everyone: the [British-supported French army] capitulated even more quickly than Poland had done" a year earlier. Shock waves crossed the Atlantic... as Paris had until then been equated with civilization throughout the non-Nazi world." Yet the attachment of the Chagalls to France "blinded them to the urgency of the situation." Many other well-known Russian and Jewish artists eventually sought to escape: these included
Chaïm Soutine,
Max Ernst,
Max Beckmann,
Ludwig Fulda, author
Victor Serge and prize-winning author
Vladimir Nabokov, who although not Jewish himself, was married to a Jewish woman. Russian author Victor Serge described many of the people living temporarily in
Marseille who were waiting to emigrate to the US: After prodding by their daughter Ida, who "perceived the need to act fast", and with help from
Alfred Barr of the
New York Museum of Modern Art, Chagall was saved by having his name added to the list of prominent artists whose lives were at risk and whom the United States should try to extricate.
Varian Fry, the US journalist, and
Hiram Bingham IV, the US Vice-Consul in Marseilles, ran a rescue operation to smuggle artists and intellectuals out of Europe to the US by providing them with forged visas to the US. In April 1941, Chagall and his wife were stripped of their French citizenship. The Chagalls stayed at the Hotel Moderne in Marseille where they were arrested along with other Jews. Varian Fry managed to pressure the French police to release him, threatening them of scandal. Chagall was one of over 2,000 who were rescued by this operation. He left France in May 1941, "when it was almost too late", adds Lewis.
Picasso and
Matisse were also invited to come to the US but they decided to remain in France. On 10 June 1941 Chagall and Bella left
Lisbon aboard the Portuguese ship
Mouzinho. The passengers included 119 refugee children, to whom Chagall gave drawing lessons on the voyage. The ship reached
Staten Island on 21 June, the day before Germany invaded the Soviet Union. Ida and her husband Michel followed on the notorious refugee ship with a large case of Chagall's work. A chance post-war meeting in a French café between Ida and intelligence analyst
Konrad Kellen led to Kellen carrying more paintings on his return to the United States.
United States (1941–1948) Even before arriving in the United States in 1941, Chagall was awarded the
Carnegie Prize third prize in 1939 for
"Les Fiancés". After being in the US he discovered that he had already achieved "international stature", writes Cogniat, although he felt ill-suited in this new role in a foreign country whose language he could not yet speak. He became a celebrity mostly against his will, feeling lost in the strange surroundings. After a while he began to settle in New York, which was full of writers, painters, and composers who, like himself, had fled from Europe during the Nazi invasions. He lived at 4
East 74th Street. He spent time visiting galleries and museums, and befriended other artists including
Piet Mondrian and
André Breton. Baal-Teshuva writes that Chagall "loved" going to the sections of New York where Jews lived, especially the
Lower East Side. There he felt at home, enjoying the Jewish foods and being able to read the Yiddish press, which became his main source of information since he did not yet speak English. Contemporary artists did not yet understand or even like Chagall's art. According to Baal-Teshuva, "they had little in common with a folkloristic storyteller of Russo-Jewish extraction with a propensity for mysticism." The Paris School, which was referred to as 'Parisian Surrealism', meant little to them. Those attitudes would begin to change, however, when
Pierre Matisse, the son of recognized French artist
Henri Matisse, became his representative and managed Chagall exhibitions in New York and Chicago in 1941. One of the earliest exhibitions included 21 of his masterpieces from 1910 to 1941. Art critic
Henry McBride wrote about this exhibit for the
New York Sun:
Aleko ballet (1942) He was offered a commission by choreographer
Léonide Massine of the
Ballet Theatre of New York to design the sets and costumes for his new ballet,
Aleko. This ballet would stage the words of
Alexander Pushkin's verse narrative
The Gypsies with the music of
Tchaikovsky. The ballet was originally planned for a New York debut, but as a cost-saving measure it was moved to Mexico where labor costs were cheaper than in New York. While Chagall had done stage settings before while in Russia, this was his first ballet, and it would give him the opportunity to visit Mexico. While there, he quickly began to appreciate the "primitive ways and colorful art of the Mexicans", notes Cogniat. He found "something very closely related to his own nature", and did all the color detail for the sets while there. Eventually, he created four large backdrops and had Mexican seamstresses sew the ballet costumes. When the ballet premiered at the
Palacio de Bellas Artes in Mexico City on 8 September 1942 it was considered a "remarkable success". In the audience were other famous mural painters who came to see Chagall's work, including
Diego Rivera and
José Clemente Orozco. According to Baal-Teshuva, when the final bar of music ended, "there was a tumultuous applause and 19 curtain calls, with Chagall himself being called back onto the stage again and again." The production then moved to New York, where it was presented four weeks later at the
Metropolitan Opera and the response was repeated, "again Chagall was the hero of the evening". Art critic
Edwin Denby wrote of the opening for the
New York Herald Tribune that Chagall's work:
Coming to grips with World War II After Chagall returned to New York in 1943 current events began to interest him more, and this was represented by his art, where he painted subjects including the
Crucifixion and scenes of war. He learned that the Germans had destroyed the town where he was raised, Vitebsk, and became greatly distressed. He also learned about the
Nazi concentration camps. During a speech in February 1944, he described some of his feelings: In the same speech he credited Soviet Russia with doing the most to save the Jews: On 2 September 1944, Bella died suddenly due to a streptococcus infection, which could not be treated at the Mercy General Hospital as they had no penicillin due to wartime restrictions. As a result, he stopped all work for many months, and when he did resume painting his first pictures were concerned with preserving Bella's memory. Wullschlager writes of the effect on Chagall: "As news poured in through 1945 of the ongoing
Holocaust at
Nazi concentration camps, Bella took her place in Chagall's mind with the millions of Jewish victims." He even considered the possibility that their "exile from Europe had sapped her will to live". in 1948 After a year of living with his daughter Ida and her husband Michel Gordey, he entered into a romance with
Virginia Haggard, daughter of diplomat
Godfrey Haggard and great-niece of the author
H. Rider Haggard; their relationship endured seven years. They had a child together, David McNeil, born 22 June 1946. Haggard recalled her "seven years of plenty" with Chagall in her book,
My Life with Chagall (Robert Hale, 1986). A few months after the Allies succeeded in liberating Paris from Nazi occupation, with the help of the Allied armies, Chagall published a letter in a Paris weekly, "To the Paris Artists":
Post-war years By 1946, his artwork was becoming more widely recognized. The
Museum of Modern Art in New York had a large exhibition representing 40 years of his work which gave visitors one of the first complete impressions of the changing nature of his art over the years. The war had ended and he began making plans to return to Paris. According to Cogniat, "He found he was even more deeply attached than before, not only to the atmosphere of Paris, but to the city itself, to its houses and its views." Chagall summed up his years living in the US: He went back to France for good during the autumn of 1947, where he attended the opening of the exhibition of his works at the
Musée National d'Art Moderne.
France (1948–1985) After returning to France he traveled throughout Europe and chose to live in the
Côte d'Azur which by that time had become somewhat of an "artistic centre".
Matisse lived near
Saint-Paul-de-Vence, about seven miles west of
Nice, while
Picasso lived in
Vallauris. Although they lived nearby and sometimes worked together, there was artistic rivalry between them as their work was so distinctly different, and they never became long-term friends. According to Picasso's mistress,
Françoise Gilot, Picasso still had a great deal of respect for Chagall, and once told her, In April 1952, Virginia Haggard left Chagall for the photographer Charles Leirens; she went on to become a professional photographer herself. Chagall's daughter Ida married art historian Franz Meyer in January 1952, and feeling that her father missed the companionship of a woman in his home, introduced him to Valentina (Vava) Brodsky, a woman from a similar Russian Jewish background, who had run a successful millinery business in London. She became his secretary, and after a few months agreed to stay only if Chagall married her. The marriage took place in July 1952—though six years later, when there was conflict between Ida and Vava, "Marc and Vava divorced and immediately remarried under an agreement more favourable to Vava" (
Jean-Paul Crespelle, author of ''Chagall, l'Amour le Reve et la Vie
, quoted in Haggard: My Life with Chagall''). In 1954, he was engaged as set decorator for
Robert Helpmann's production of
Rimsky-Korsakov's opera ''
Le Coq d'Or'' at the
Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, but he withdrew. The Australian designer
Loudon Sainthill was drafted at short notice in his place. In the years ahead he was able to produce not just paintings and graphic art, but also numerous sculptures and ceramics, including wall tiles, painted vases, plates and jugs. He also began working in larger-scale formats, producing large murals, stained glass windows, mosaics and tapestries.
Ceiling of the Paris Opera (1963) In 1963, Chagall was commissioned to paint the new ceiling for the Paris Opera (
Palais Garnier), a majestic 19th-century building and national monument.
André Malraux, France's Minister of Culture wanted something unique and decided Chagall would be the ideal artist. However, this choice of artist caused controversy: some objected to having a Russian Jew decorate a French national monument; others disliked the ceiling of the historic building being painted by a modern artist. Some magazines wrote condescending articles about Chagall and Malraux, about which Chagall commented to one writer: Nonetheless, Chagall continued the project, which took the 77-year-old artist a year to complete. The final canvas was nearly 2,400 square feet (220 sq. meters) and required of paint. It had five sections which were glued to polyester panels and hoisted up to the ceiling. The images Chagall painted on the canvas paid tribute to the composers
Mozart,
Wagner,
Mussorgsky,
Berlioz and
Ravel, as well as to famous actors and dancers. It was presented to the public on 23 September 1964 in the presence of Malraux and 2,100 invited guests. The Paris correspondent for the
New York Times wrote, "For once the best seats were in the uppermost circle: Baal-Teshuva writes: After the new ceiling was unveiled, "even the bitterest opponents of the commission seemed to fall silent", writes Baal-Teshuva. "Unanimously, the press declared Chagall's new work to be a great contribution to French culture." Malraux later said, "What other living artist could have painted the ceiling of the Paris Opera in the way Chagall did?... He is above all one of the great colourists of our time... many of his canvases and the Opera ceiling represent sublime images that rank among the finest poetry of our time, just as
Titian produced the finest poetry of his day." In Chagall's speech to the audience he explained the meaning of the work: ==Art styles and techniques==