The club had closed down during the war, so Webb's first task was not only rebuilding the team but also involving himself with rebuilding the ground. He earned a reputation as a sound judge of a player. Immediately after the war, the signing of former
England international forward
George Holley for a club record £200 fee was viewed as quite a coup. Holley suffered a career-ending injury, so hardly played, but Webb replaced him with
Jack Doran who finished as the club's top scorer despite joining halfway through the season. He brought
Tommy Cook through from the juniors into the first team; Cook was top scorer in three seasons, but when he left the club to concentrate on his
cricket career, Webb brought in the
Queens Park Rangers reserve
Hugh Vallance, who turned out to be a "goalscoring phenomenon" alongside
Dan Kirkwood. Again, when twice top scorer
Arthur Attwood succumbed to
appendicitis in 1933, Webb signed former
Norwich City centre-forward
Oliver "Buster" Brown who had failed to break into the first team at
West Ham Unitedwith regular football at Albion, Brown produced 41 goals in his first two seasons. Between the wars, Webb's teams finished in the top five of the Third Division South on ten occasions, but challenged seriously for promotion only in the latter half of the 1930s. He led the team to third place in 1936–37, despite an uneasy relationship with the club's board, the supporters, and the press. The board came under criticism for alleged interference in team affairs, having undue influence over the manager in pressing the claims for selection of one player over another. Letters to the local press suggested that Webb should "be allowed greater freedom", while in the
Evening Argus, the pseudonymous "Crusader"'s "vitriolic attacks on the directors and management of Brighton and Hove Albion for their alleged lack of ambition and inept team selections ... generated a massive readership response" and led to "near physical confrontations with Charlie Webb, the beleaguered manager and former Albion player, despite the team usually finishing in a respectable position in the League table." The club's relationship with the local newspaper worsened during the 1937–38 season, to the extent that "Crusader" was "either banned by the directors or was voluntarily taken off by [the editor]". Webb himself told the
Daily Express: "Here you have a town full of people with money, yet hardly one of them will give us a hand. Without attractive new players and a winning team you can't get gates and without gates you can't have money." Nevertheless, the national press recognised his achievements. A
Daily Mirror feature in 1939 compared him to
George Allison of
Arsenal and
Frank Buckley of
Wolverhampton Wanderers, A
Guardian retrospective on the club, written in 1973, described how "Brighton had a skilful team usually playing to the top six" under Webb, "whose transfer acquisitions were as often as not costed on the price of his train ticket and buffet sandwiches". ==Second World War and after==