In the post-Mao era, there were major debates on the role that contradictions and alienation played within a Socialist society.
Deng Xiaoping personally intervened against the
Marxist humanist trend in insisting that alienation was solely based on private property, and had no place in a socialist China. In his 1983 speech, Deng said that: As to alienation, after Marx discovered the law of surplus value, he used that term only to describe wage labour in capitalist society, meaning that such labour was alien to the workers themselves and was performed against their will, so that the capitalist might profit at their expense. Yet, in discussing alienation, some of our comrades go beyond capitalism; some even ignore the remaining alienation of labour under capitalism and its consequences. Rather, they allege that alienation exists under socialism and can be found in the economic, political, and ideological realms, that, in the course of its development, socialism constantly gives rise to a force of alienation, as a result of the activities of the main body of the society. Moreover, they try to explain our reform from the point of view of overcoming this alienation. Thus, they cannot help people to correctly understand and solve the problems that have arisen in socialist society today, or to correctly understand and carry out the continual reform that is essential for our technological and social advance. On the contrary, their position will only lead people to criticize, doubt, and negate socialism, to consider it as hopeless as capitalism and to renounce their confidence in the future of socialism and communism. "So what's the point of building socialism?" they say. Despite Deng's condemnation, High Culture Fever continued to rise in China, with the work of
Fredric Jameson being particularly popular. == Jiang Zemin's "Three Represents"==