Swift produced "Christmas Tree Farm" with
Jimmy Napes, who provided background vocals and played piano. Gus Pirelli played
Moog bass and recorded the track at London Lane Studios in the United Kingdom, assisted by Jamie McEvoy, Joseph Wander, and Will Purton.
Serban Ghenea provided
audio mixing, with John Hanes serving as the
mixing engineer.
Simon Hale conducted the
string arrangement and Lawrence Johnson worked as the vocal arranger. Musicians who played instruments for "Christmas Tree Farm" include Bruce White (viola), Jodi Milliner (
bass guitar), Ian Burdge (
cello), Chris Laurence (
double bass), and Ash Soan (drums); John Thurgood, Laurence Davies, and Martin Owen played
French horn. Several singers provided choral background vocals, including Candice-Mimi Otohwo, Destinee Knight-Scott, Glenn Tatenda Gwazai, Jessica Mae Obioha, Lorrain Briscoe, Margeaux Michelle, Paul Lee, Tarna Renae Johnson, Tehillah Daniel, The LJ Singers, Travis J Cole, Wayne Hernandez, and Wendi Rose. It is a Christmas-themed
pop song and a
sentimental ballad that features an
upbeat arrangement, an
uptempo rhythm, and 1960s music influences. It begins with a
jazzy intro showcasing 1950s-inspired
strings, which was compared to the music of
Nat King Cole and
Karen Carpenter by
The A.V. Club Gwen Ihnat. The song then transitions into the main upbeat pop part that features
jingle bell percussion; critics stated that it evoked the music of
Mariah Carey and
Phil Spector. Featuring a new arrangement and a 70-piece
orchestra, the "Old Timey Version" incorporates horns, strings, and muted jingle bells along with elements of
swing music. The lyrics recall Swift's nostalgic childhood memories from an adult perspective. In the
intro, she expresses her stress amid the chaotic nature of the holiday season, before she closes her eyes and envisions being in a different place. She wishes to visit the Christmas tree farm in her heart and depicts a fanciful scene: "In my heart is a Christmas tree farm/ Where the people would come/ To dance under sparkling lights/ Bundled up in their mittens and coats/ And the cider would flow/ And I just wanna be there tonight." Swift sings in the
hook to her lover, "Everything is icy and blue/ And you would be there too", before admitting in the
refrain, "Just being in your arms/ Takes me back to that little farm/ Where every wish comes true." ==Critical reception==