, Finley lives in
Newport Beach, California.
Marriage Finley was married to actress
Tawny Kitaen from 1997 to 2002. They had two daughters. Finley and Kitaen were featured together in the 1999
Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue. On April 4, 2002, Finley filed for divorce three days after Kitaen was charged with committing
domestic violence against him, twisting his ear and having beaten him repeatedly with a
stiletto heel in the arm, leg and foot while he was driving a car in
Orange County, California, two weeks earlier. In the divorce filings, he stated, "I am fearful that (Kitaen)... will harm herself or will harm others, including me or including my children." He received a temporary
restraining order preventing her from seeing him and he received temporary custody of the children. During hearings on the domestic violence charge of spousal abuse, Kitaen initially pleaded not guilty but admitted that she was addicted to prescription medications which she had taken for two years for
migraines, and voluntarily entered both substance abuse treatment and
anger management classes for 52 weeks to get the charges dropped. Tawny Finley, in a declaration to the Orange County Superior Court, claimed Finley used
steroids, among other drugs. She also claimed he bragged about being able to circumvent
MLB's testing policy. When told of his wife's accusations, which also included heavy
marijuana use and alcohol abuse, Finley replied: "I can't believe she left out the
cross-dressing." So prevalent was his personal life troubles that in April 16, 2002, road game against the
Chicago White Sox, the
Comiskey Park musical director took a subtle dig at Finley's messy divorce, The musical director was later fired, and the White Sox apologized. Finley's third daughter Briena was born in 2007 from a relationship at the time.
Library Scandal In 2016, staff at the East Lake County Library in
Sorrento, Florida, created a fictitious patron named “Chuck Finley” to manipulate the library’s circulation records. The name, borrowed from retired Major League Baseball pitcher Chuck Finley, was used to check out over 2,600 books within a nine-month period. The scheme was designed to prevent the library’s automated weeding system from discarding titles that had not been borrowed for an extended time. Library officials claimed this practice helped retain popular books that would otherwise have been removed and later repurchased. Following an anonymous tip, an investigation by the Lake County Clerk of Courts’ inspector general’s office uncovered multiple fabricated accounts, leading to the suspension of staff involved and a system-wide audit of the county’s libraries. While the librarians did not personally benefit from the scheme, their actions as an attempt to “teach the system” how to better reflect reader interest rather than rely solely on circulation metrics. The former major league pitcher was not involved in the scandal. ==Honors==