Cleveland Indians Crisp became the starting center fielder with the Indians in mid-2002, replacing the injured
Matt Lawton. For the next few seasons, Crisp established a reputation as an excellent fielder and speedy baserunner. Despite his success, Crisp had to fight for his roster spot each
spring. In 2005, Crisp moved to
left field following the emergence of another young outfielder,
Grady Sizemore. In his final two seasons with the Indians, Crisp showcased his offensive talent by batting .297 and .300 with 31 total home runs and 35
steals.
Boston Red Sox After
Johnny Damon signed with the
New York Yankees, the Red Sox sought Crisp to fill Damon's role as both leadoff hitter and in center field. In January 2006, the Red Sox sent prospect
third baseman Andy Marte, pitcher
Guillermo Mota,
catcher Kelly Shoppach, a
player to be named later (minor leaguer
Randy Newsom), and cash considerations to the Indians for Crisp, catcher
Josh Bard and pitcher
David Riske. in 2007. On April 12, 2006, Crisp signed a three-year contract extension with the Red Sox worth $15.5 million. Crisp broke his left index finger attempting to steal third base earlier in the month and spent the next 42 games on the
disabled list. After returning to the Red Sox outfield on May 28,
Kevin Youkilis had taken over the leadoff spot, and Crisp usually batted seventh or eighth in the
line-up for the rest of the year. In 105 games, he had a .264 batting average with eight home runs and 36 RBI. Besides his injury, Crisp's 2006 season may be best remembered for a catch against the
New York Mets on June 29.
2007 season Crisp began the 2007 season struggling offensively due to lingering effects of off season surgery to his left index finger. On April 20, 2007, Crisp fell over a short wall at
Fenway Park while trying to catch a home run by
Alex Rodriguez. Although he was unable to make the catch, missing by inches, he hit a game-tying
triple off
Mariano Rivera in the bottom of the eighth, then scored the go-ahead run on
Alex Cora's soft line drive single. The Red Sox went on to win 7–6. During this season, he made numerous impressive catches in the outfield. It has even been claimed by one major league club that Crisp is easily the best defensive center fielder in all of Major League Baseball. Although he struggled at the plate throughout much of the season, between June 13 and July 23, Crisp raised his batting average from .221 to .284, a .402 average during that span. On June 18, entering the game with only two home runs in the season, Crisp belted two homers in the first multi-HR game of his career in a 9–4 loss to the
Atlanta Braves. On August 5, Crisp was almost run over by the
Seattle Mariners' mascot, the
Mariner Moose. The Moose, driving a lap around
Safeco Field's warning track on an
ATV, nearly collided with Crisp as he was leaving the
dugout for his position in the middle of the fifth inning; Crisp had to jump out of the way to avoid being hit. Red Sox pitching coach
John Farrell was incensed by the mascot's actions and voiced his displeasure to both the mascot and Seattle's head groundskeeper. Immediately following the incident, the Red Sox received an apology from Mariners GM
Bill Bavasi. On October 21, in Game 7 of the
American League Championship Series, Crisp made the catch that sent Boston to their second
World Series in four seasons. He hit the wall shortly after making the catch, slightly injuring himself in the process. Despite this, he was well enough to play in the World Series. Although he was the team's starting center fielder throughout the 2007 season, he was benched mid-series during the ALCS for rookie
Jacoby Ellsbury. He remained benched for the
2007 World Series, only appearing late in games for defensive substitutions.
2008 season on June 5, 2008. On June 4, Crisp was the center of controversy in a game against the
Tampa Bay Rays. While Crisp was trying to steal
second base in the bottom of the sixth inning, Rays shortstop
Jason Bartlett purposely placed his knee in front of the bag in an attempt to prevent Crisp from stealing the base. Crisp stole the base, but was not happy with this. On base again in the bottom of the eighth inning, he attempted another steal, this time taking out second baseman
Akinori Iwamura on a hard slide. His slide was controversial and catalyzed the "payback pitch" the following game. During a pitching change in that inning, Rays manager
Joe Maddon and Crisp argued, with Crisp in the dugout and Maddon on the pitching mound. After the game, Crisp said that he thought Bartlett would cover the bag, instead he (Bartlett) chose to tell Iwamura to take the throw in the eighth inning. Crisp described Bartlett's knee in front of the bag as a "Dirty" play. During the next game, with Crisp at bat in the bottom of the second inning, and the Sox up 3–1, Rays starter
James Shields hit him on the thigh on the second pitch. Crisp
charged the mound and first dodged a punch from Shields, and then threw a glancing punch at Shields, which set off a
bench-clearing brawl. Crisp,
Jonny Gomes, and Shields were ejected from the game. Major League Baseball suspended Crisp for seven games due to his actions in the brawl. Upon appeal, the suspension was reduced to five games, which he had served as of June 28, 2008. In Game 5 of the
ALCS, Crisp had a game-tying hit in the bottom of the eighth inning to cap Boston's seven-run comeback. Boston would go on to win the game 8–7 with a walk-off single in the ninth inning by
J. D. Drew, but eventually lost the series in seven games. .
Kansas City Royals On November 19, 2008, Crisp was traded to the
Kansas City Royals for relief pitcher
Ramón Ramírez. During his lone season with the Royals, Crisp started off hot, hitting well over .300 before his
batting average fell to a career low .228 due to shoulder injuries. On June 23, 2009, Royals manager
Trey Hillman announced that Crisp would receive season ending surgeries to repair a
labrum tear in both shoulders.
Oakland Athletics After the 2009 season, Crisp signed a one-year contract with the
Oakland Athletics worth $5 million, with a club option for 2011. Crisp began the 2010 season on the 15-day DL with a fractured left pinkie finger. Crisp entered the 2011 season exercising his one-year option with the
Oakland Athletics. On August 24, Crisp homered from both sides of the plate against the
New York Yankees. In that game, he hit a game-winning three-run home run in the top of the 10th inning on the first pitch he saw against reliever
Rafael Soriano. He finished the season with an AL-leading 49 stolen bases. Crisp re-signed with Athletics on January 3, 2012, on a two-year, $14 million deal with a club option for 2014. Crisp had received other offers from clubs such as the
Baltimore Orioles and
Chicago White Sox as well, but declined them both. On October 10, 2012, in Game 4 of the
2012 American League Division Series against the
Detroit Tigers, Crisp came to bat in the bottom of the ninth inning. The score was tied 3–3, there were two outs and a runner on second base (
Seth Smith). The A's were down 3–1 entering the inning, but subsequently tied the game with three straight hits off Detroit pitcher
José Valverde, thus setting the stage for Crisp. He came through with a walk-off single to right field that scored Smith, giving the A's a 4–3 win and forcing a decisive Game 5. On October 11, 2012, the Tigers finished off the series with a 6–0 victory over the A's. After the 2013 season, the Athletics exercised their club option on Crisp for the 2014 season. Before the 2014 season, Crisp signed an extension with the Athletics covering the 2015 and 2016 seasons. The contract guaranteed him $11 million in each of the 2015 and 2016 seasons, and had a vesting option for the 2017 season. Crisp's playing time was reduced in 2016, leading him to believe that the Athletics were intentionally preventing his 2017 option from vesting. In 2015, he batted a career-low .175 and had the lowest on-base percentage (.252) and slugging percentage (.222) of his career, as on defense he played exclusively in left field.
Return to Cleveland before game three of the
2016 American League Division Series On August 31, 2016, the Athletics traded Crisp with cash considerations to the Indians for
Colt Hynes. Before he agreed to waive his no-trade clause,
Chris Antonetti, the Indians'
general manager, spoke with Crisp to tell him that he would not receive enough playing time in Cleveland for his option to vest. In 2016, he batted .208 for Cleveland. It was Crisp's second career postseason home run. However, he and the Indians could not hold on in the World Series, losing the series in seven games to the
Chicago Cubs. ==Post-playing career==