During the 1960s and 1970s, the downtown retail sector in Indianapolis was in decline as suburban shopping centers were opening. Vacancy rates were increasing and the physical environment was deteriorating. The lack of restaurants and other attractions led to fewer people coming downtown during the evening and on weekends. Negotiations to purchase the real estate on the north side of Washington Street proved to be difficult. In particular, the Goodman family owned the
Goodman Jewelers Building and several other buildings (including the
Taylor Carpet Company Building and the
Selig's Dry Goods Company Building) east of Illinois Street and, while the Goodmans wanted to be part of the mall, their valuation of their properties and their vision for the mall differed from those of the mall developers. As a result, the city decided to relocate the mall to the south side of Washington Street. In 1983, the city began purchasing the needed property. The Occidental Building at the southeast corner of Washington and Illinois streets, which was the home of the
L. Strauss & Co. clothing store, was bought for $2.8 million. Strauss moved to the new Claypool Courts at the northwest corner of the same intersection, but went out of business before the mall itself was completed. On April 1, 2021, day-to-day management of the mall was taken over by
JLL. Simon continued to handle leasing, until they sold their remaining stake in December 2021 to the Circle Centre Development Company. In December 2023, the Circle Centre Development Company announced that it had reached an agreement to sell the mall to Hendricks Commercial Properties. Hendricks had previously redeveloped the other public spaces in Indiana plans to spend about $600 million over the next ten years to redevelop the mall into an “open air, pedestrian-focused campus with housing, offices and shopping”. The acquisition was completed on April 24, 2024. The mall closed permanently on December 31, 2025, to allow the redevelopment to begin. The first phase, which is targeted to open in 2029, will include of retail, dining, and entertainment; of office space, and more than 300 apartments, along with public plazas and green spaces. Restaurants and other businesses that face the streets will continue to operate during the redevelopment. The campus will be known as Traction Yards. ==Historic preservation==