While intended to be a positive descriptor to distinguish between trans and non-trans identity, the term has been met with criticisms in more recent years.
From feminism and gender studies Krista Scott-Dixon wrote in 2009 that she preferred "the term
non-trans to other options such as
cissexual/
cisgendered", saying
non-trans is clearer to average people. Gender studies professor Chris Freeman criticizes the term, describing it as "clunky, unhelpful and maybe even regressive" and saying it "createsor re-createsa gender binary". The term cisgender "can get confusing" in relation to people with intersex conditions, although some intersex people use the term according to the
Interact Advocates for Intersex Youth Inter/Act project.
Hida Viloria of
Intersex Campaign for Equality notes that, as a person born with an intersex body who has a non-binary sense of gender identity that "matches" their body, they are both cisgender and gender non-conforming, presumably opposites according to
cisgender definition, and that this evidences the term's basis on a binary sex model that does not account for intersex people's existence. Viloria also critiques the fact that the term
sex assigned at birth is used in one of
cisgender definitions without noting that babies are assigned male or female regardless of intersex status in most of the world, stating that doing so obfuscates the birth of intersex babies and frames gender identity within a binary male/female sex model that fails to account for both the existence of natally congruent gender non-conforming gender identities, and gender-based discrimination against intersex people based on natal sex characteristics rather than on gender identity or expression, such as "normalizing"
infant genital surgeries.
From Elon Musk In June 2023,
Elon Musk, owner of social network
Twitter (now X), stated that use of the words "cis" and "cisgender" on the platform as "targeted harassment" would constitute violations of its hateful content policy, as he considered them to be
slurs. The changes came following an interaction between Musk and a gender-critical commentator, who alleged that pro-trans advocates were using forms of the word (such as "cissy", a variant of the pejorative
sissy) to insult him following a post in which he rejected the term. Musk has since described cisgender as being "
heterophobic" and a "heterosexual slur". The change came amid the loosening of other rules protecting LGBT users
under his ownership, including removing rules prohibiting
deadnaming.
Responses to critiques After the Oxford Dictionary added
cisgender as a word in 2015,
The Advocate wrote that "even among LGBT people, the word is hotly debated"; transgender veteran Brynn Tannehill argued that it was "often used in a negative way" by trans people to express "a certain level of contempt" for people they think should not partake in discussions on trans issues. == See also ==