1892 election Matthews was nominated to run as the Democratic candidate for governor in 1892 and ran in the fall election against incumbent Republican governor
Ira Joy Chase and Populist candidate Leroy Templeton. The campaign focused primarily on depressed farm prices and farmers desires to inflate the currency to alleviate debt problems. Matthews won the election by seven thousand votes. The Populist party failed to make significant gains in the state, and the election marked the party's decline in the state.
Conflict with the General Assembly As the 1894 mid-term elections neared, Republicans were able to secure blame for the poor economic situation on the Democrats, and swept into power in the statehouse, taking strong majorities in both houses. The legislative districts created in 1890 were a subject of intense debate at the time; the legislature during the term of Governor
Isaac P. Gray had created several
gerrymander districts that favored Democrats. Republicans had contested the districting in the courts, who ruled the state must be redistricted. The Democrats had done so in 1893, but the Republicans overrode their redistricting upon taking power, and created their own plan which effectively reversed the situation and created pro-Republican gerrymander districts.
1896 presidential bid Before his term as governor ended, Matthews was nominated by
David Turpie to run for president at the
1896 Democratic National Convention held in
Chicago. Matthews was a leading candidate until the sixth ballot when his supporters switched to
William Jennings Bryan after Bryan delivered an impassioned speech. Matthews left office and returned to his farm.
Later life and death He continued making occasional public appearances and delivering speeches. While delivering a speech in
Montgomery County, he suffered a stroke and died three days later in an
Indianapolis hospital on August 28, 1898. His body was returned to his home town and buried in a Clinton cemetery. ==Electoral history==