The play's plot proceeds as a series of monologues about the life of
Ty Cobb and his
era of baseball. Three versions of Cobb at different ages talk about their memory of their life in baseball, with
Negro leagues player
Oscar Charleston also appearing to correct or challenge Cobb's perspective. The play is one-act with no intermission. The Peach reflects on Cobb's early playing career and the murder of his father by his mother when Cobb was 18. He also gleefully speaks on how he would pick fights on and off the field, often with black people. The character Ty re-frames his violent tendencies as something he would do to throw off his competitors. He also expresses bitterness at his divorce, his unpopularity, and the course baseball has taken by the end of his career. Mr. Cobb again reframes aspects of his life, taking a more melancholic view. Though he was chosen to be part of the first class of
Baseball Hall of Fame inductees, he feels that baseball left him behind. In one monologue, Ty describes his process to scoring runs by taunting the pitcher, using his sharpened cleat-spikes to intimidate infielders, and
manufacturing bases before he ultimately steals
home. He expresses his resentment of
Babe Ruth, who both shifted playing style away from Cobb's
small-ball style toward his own
long-ball style and who became beloved among fans. Ruth reappears in the dialogue as a foil for Cobb, with set decorations often displaying his image. Oscar Charleston often appears throughout the narrative, to talk about his own playing career and antagonize the various Cobbs. Charleston was himself a superlative player and a center-fielder with a known temper, so he was referred to as the "Black Cobb" by the white baseball press. Though Cobb's
Detroit Tigers occasionally played exhibition games against Charleston's
Indianapolis ABCs between 1915 and 1923, Cobb would refuse to participate. Charleston taunts the Cobbs that he was the better player, unfalsifiable as they never played each other on the diamond. == Characters ==