Towards the end of the 18th century the Church of England was facing a number of problems and challenges. Due to factors including the
Industrial Revolution, the population of Britain had grown, and it had redistributed, tending to concentrate in urban centres: some older and expanded, others newly created. Meanwhile, the organisation of the Church of England had not been modified to reflect this change, leading to a mismatch between the population and the pastoral services provided by the church. For example,
Stockport with a population of nearly 34,000 had church seating for only 2,500,
Sheffield had 6,280 seats for 55,000 people,
Manchester had 11,000 for nearly 80,000, and the
St Marylebone district of London had only 8,700 places for 76,624 inhabitants. In addition, there was a concern in society that, following the
French Revolution of 1789–99, there might be a similar uprising in Britain. It was considered that "the influence of the Church and its religious and moral teaching was a bulwark against revolution." Some argued that a major function of the church was to complement the work of the state; that "the church's main function was social control". On top of this, the Church of England had its own internal problems, some of them even amounting to abuses, such as pluralism (
vicars owning more than one
benefice), absenteeism (vicars employing
curates to run their parishes) and non-residence. There was a great disparity between the incomes of the parochial clergy. The educational level of the clergy and their training was often inadequate. Challenges to the church came from two main sources,
dissent and
secularism. Dissenters were those Christians who did not ascribe to the practices of the
established church (the Church of England), and they included the older
independent churches such as the
Quakers,
Baptists and
Congregationalists, and the newer movement of
Methodism. The rise of these movements was blamed partly on the lack of accommodation in the churches provided by the state church. A major impediment to increasing the number of churches in the newly expanded towns was the difficulty in providing a regular income for an incumbent parson. Most parish livings in the Church of England were then primarily supported from agricultural
tithes collected from farms in the parish. In expanding towns and cities, new churches had tended to be provided in association with residential developments as
proprietary chapels, whose licensed ministers received an income from
pew rents. Neither method of finance had proved capable of funding the provision of clergy for poorer urban populations. During the early 1810s groups were formed to address these problems by both active parties in the Church of England, the
Evangelicals and the
High Churchmen.
Joshua Watson, a
layman, was a prominent member of the High Church group; he has been described as "the greatest lay churchman of his day" and was to become "the cornerstone of the [Church Building] Commission", on which he served for 33 years. Because of the legal structure of the Church of England, it was "almost indispensable to obtain an Act of Parliament before a church was rebuilt, or a new one built " and "to divide a parish an Act was essential". There was growing pressure for Parliament to meet the problems. Following the defeat of Napoleon in 1815 there was also a movement to build churches "as a "national thank-offering". In December 1815 Joshua Watson and the
pamphleteer John Bowdler, wrote a "memorial" to the
prime minister,
Lord Liverpool, arguing the case for more churches. There was initial reluctance from the politicians to agree to the proposal, partly because of the financial deficit following the
Napoleonic Wars. In 1817 a committee was appointed to form a society for "promoting public worship by obtaining additional church-room for the middle and lower classes". This was successful and at a public meeting on 6 February 1818 in the
Freemasons' Hall, London, chaired by
Charles Manners-Sutton, the
Archbishop of Canterbury, the
Duke of Northumberland proposed a motion to form the Church Building Society, and this was accepted. This led to Parliament's agreement to provide the First Parliamentary Grant of £1 million for building new churches. The Church Building Act 1818 (
58 Geo. 3. c. 45) was debated in Parliament and passed later that year. ==The commission==