The first hotel to open in the area (circa 1883) was reported somewhat confusingly in newspapers of the day as either the
"Woronora",
"Woniora",
"Wiganora" or
"Worinora" Hotel (see Timeline below for details). Newspaper references to a second, larger establishment that was constructed circa January 1887 and known generally as the
"Como Hotel" do not appear until June 1887 (also see Timeline further down page for extensive detail)
The Woronora Hotel Timeline • Circa 1882/83 – First established by proprietor Mr Thomas Hanley (aka Handley), the
"Woronora Hotel" was a
"humble hostelry" – a modest size weatherboard & iron roofed building, located near the southern shore of the Georges River & close by the first railway workers' tent camp, that also contained worker's wives & children, for a total population of around 120. • 12 May 1883 – A notice in the Sydney Morning Herald states – ''"POST OFFICES. – Post offices will be established on the 16th instant, at Como (Railway Crossing, George's River), near Woniora;"
This is the first public reference to the fact that the old locality of "Woronora"
had officially been changed to "Como"
(on the suggestion of James Murphy, manager of the Holt-Sutherland Co.) The "Como Post Office"'' was built adjacent to Hanley's
"Woronora Hotel" & Thomas managed both businesses. • 10 July 1883 – A report in the Sydney Morning Herald on the progress of the Illawarra Railway Line extension at Georges River states – ''"The other side of the river near to the mouth of the Woronora presents a busy scene. Here the line begins to pass over the Holt-Sutherland Estate. There is a little town of canvas, with an hotel of weatherboards and a post-office of currugated iron. This post-office is called "Como", on account of the beauty of its natural surroundings and the lovely lake-like character of George's River from this point to the eastward, second only to the celebrated "Lago di Como", so well known to travellers on the continent of Europe".
However, Thomas Hanley retained the name "Woronora Hotel"
for his small enterprise located adjacent to the "Como Post Office"''. • 17 May 1884 –
Australian Town and Country Journal (Sydney) reports that at Como, Georges River,
"There is a capital hotel called the Worinora, kept by Mr Hanley." • 15 September 1884 – The Evening News (Sydney) reported a destructive fire had destroyed Mr Hanley's Post Office & store next to his
"Worinora Hotel" with the loss of all postal records. An enquiry was held in October with an open finding. • 27 September 1884 – The Australian Town and Country Journal reports that at Como, Georges River,
"The petition of the inhabitants, relative to a railway station, has at length been acceded to, the site chosen being at the rear of the Worinora Hotel." • 29 December 1885 – A report in the Daily Telegraph titled "A Trip To Como And Sutherland" notes –
"At present there is only a platform at Como, but an embryo hotel is visible as the sign of a coming civilisation". The "emryo hotel" referred to being the otherwise titled
"Woronora Hotel". • Mid 1886 – A rare, historic photo taken shortly after the first single track Como Station had been constructed in early 1886 • 28 December 1886 – A critique in the Sydney Morning Herald laments the lack at Como of
"...a suitable place for the refreshment of the inner man. The Wiganora (sic) Hotel, respectably as it is conducted by Mr William Stevenson, is altogether inadequate for the demands made upon it at holiday time" and continues
"...the owners of the Holt-Sutherland Estate might well consider whether it would not be to their interest to grant some enterprising capitalist a lease upon such liberal terms as would induce public to the district". This may have led the Holt-Sutherland Estate partners to invest in starting to build what would become the 1st version of the Como Hotel, with its first Licensee to be George Agnew. • 24 May 1887 – In the meantime, following the public criticism (above), some renovations and extensions must have been made to the Woronora Hotel, as what would be the last advertisement for the fully licensed
"Woronora Hotel" was placed in the Sydney Morning Herald, proclaiming – ''"COMO. COMO. COMO. – WORONORA HOTEL, Como, George's River. This hotel is now open. If you wish to spend an enjoyable day visit Como on Queen's Birthday, where you can get wines, spirits, and beers, of best brands. Also Pleasure and Fishing Boats for Hire."''. Also note that the newly constructed competitor for the tourist trade becoming known in the media as "Agnew's Hotel" or simply the
"Como Hotel" was NOT licensed at that time to serve liquor. • 25 May 1887 – A reporter in an article about the recently opened Illawarra Line at Como, makes mention of
"An hotel known as the Woronora
Hotel, which marks another stage in the progress of the place, has just been opened at Como, and will, no doubt, prove a great convenience to visitors on holidays and other occasions". Within a month, the newly constructed first version of the "Como Hotel" (though with only a provisional license, not yet legally able to sell alcohol) had advertised "Open for business", with meals and accommodation for pick-nickers, day-trippers and tourists. It appears this increased competition for income from wealthier tourists visiting Como from this new, larger hotel caused the lesser
"Woronora Hotel" to be closed down (presumably within the same year) since no more articles or advertisements referring to the
"Woronora Hotel" are to be found in the various newspapers of the time following the last advertisement listed here.
The Como Hotel There appear to have been three (3) distinct versions of this establishment over time.
Original The first version of the
"Como Hotel" was relatively small, made of weatherboard and iron-roofed. Its construction was most likely funded by the Holt-Sutherland Estate partners (who owned all the commercial land leases at Como). It was completed circa Jan 1887 by the remaining immigrant railway workers (and was known colloquially as the
"German Club"). However, it appears from subsequent newspaper advertisements of the time to have been licensed for accommodation only (those "refreshment needs" being served by Mr William Stevenson, a new Licensee of the so-called "Woronora Hotel" nearby). Unlike the advertisements for the
"Woronora Hotel" espousing the availability of all forms of liquor, the first advertisements being placed by George Agnew for the early version of the
"Como Hotel" NEVER mention the availability of spirits or alcoholic drinks – only meals, tea, coffee, accommodation, fishing, shooting, boat hire etc.
Timeline • 28 December 1886 – A critique in the Sydney Morning Herald laments the lack at Como of "...a suitable place for the refreshment of the inner man. The Wiganora (sic) Hotel, respectably as it is conducted by Mr William Stevenson, is altogether inadequate for the demands made upon it at holiday time" and continues "...the owners of the Holt-Sutherland Estate might well consider whether it would not be to their interest to grant some enterprising capitalist a lease upon such liberal terms as would induce public to the district".[43] This may have led the Holt-Sutherland Estate partners to invest in starting to build what would become the 1st version of the Como Hotel, with its first Licensee to be George Agnew. • Circa Jan 1887 – Work on constructing the 1st (much smaller) build of the
"Como Hotel" was completed mostly by the available remaining German & Italian railway workers, apparently followed by a few months of equipping & fitting out. • 2 May 1887 – James Murphy, manager of the Holt-Sutherland Estate Land Co., Limited, places an advertisement in the Sydney Morning Herald for the
"LEASE OF HOTEL AT COMO" adding
"The Buildings have just had extensive alterations and additions made, and a NEW LICENSE HAS BEEN GRANTED". • 20 June 1887 – The first advertisement appears in the Sydney Morning Herald for ''"AGNEW'S COMO HOTEL. If you wish to spend an enjoyable day, don't forget to visit COMO. The scenery cannot be surpassed in the colony. First class accommodation for visitors. Luncheon provided. Also splendid fishing grounds. Boats for Hire. GEORGE AGNEW, PROPRIETOR"'' Note that this advertisement mentions accommodation & meals only, since a Publican's License to legally sell liquor had not been granted. • 1 January 1888 – In what should have been a boon for both Hotels, the first major sale of residential land blocks at Como (comprising 119 Lots) was undertaken on behalf of the Holt-Sutherland Estate by agents
Richardson & Wrench. • 17 March 1888 – An advertisement is placed in the Sydney Morning Herald by George Agnew for the ''"COMO HOTEL, Como, George's River, Illawarra Line. Parties staying at Hotel can have use of private Boats for fishing &c. Tea and coffee at all hours. Terms moderate"''. Note that again, there is NO mention of any availability of liquor or alcoholic beverages. The tone is of a friendly, family oriented theme being promoted. The definitive history and fate of the 1st version of the
"Como Hotel" – apart from the scant few newspaper articles referred to here – is unclear. There appear to be no newspaper records relating to its initial construction, and no references that could help determine whether it was demolished outright and totally replaced by the second, much larger Edwardian styled version, or was simply incorporated into the second build (though that seems unlikely, given that the second version built circa 1888–1889 used 160,000 bricks in its ground floor).
Second version The first version of the
"Como Hotel" (also known colloquially as the
"German Club") must have been considered inadequate for the ongoing plans of the Holt-Sutherland Estate partners, who wished to develop a large number of residential blocks at Como & thus needed to entice buyers to the area. Barely a year later, on 30 March 1888, it was reported that George Agnew (first proprietor of "Agnew's Como Hotel") had submitted plans & applied for a Conditional License to construct a much bigger, brand new 16 room hotel (on a new Lease within the Holt-Sutherland Estate at Como). The License for this new build was granted one month later, in April 1888. Tenders sought by building contractor Robert Fielding were called during Dec 1889 – Feb 1890 for sub-contractors to supply large quantities of building materials & carry out associated works, including the delivery of 160,000 bricks, quarrying local stone, providing and erecting large quantities of iron posts, railings & ornamental castings, providing plumbing & plastering work etc. Construction of this much grander, Edwardian-styled, multi-story Hotel establishment was completed by the end of June 1890. Early photos were taken circa 1894 clearly show the facade(s) bore an Establishment Year of "1890" in an artistic "cartouche" style, being a large "1" overlaid with a smaller "8", with "9" to the left and "0" to the right of the centrally aligned "1" & "8" combination. Unfortunately, during 1890 Australian economic conditions worsened rapidly, with many large strikes crippling large industries (maritime, wool, coal etc.). The following 3 years saw a terrible economic Depression set in across the country. Unsurprisingly, due either to these prevailing poor business conditions (or just poor management), the first ten years of operation of the grand Edwardian styled version of the
"Como Hotel" got off to a very rocky start. First proprietor George Agnew must have spent so much building the establishment that he was forced to advertise for a buyer/lessee soon after he had opened it. However, having failed to get a suitable buyer/lessee for his hotel after four months (Jul 1890 to Oct 1890), he himself was forced to apply for a Conditional Publican's License while continuing to search for a buyer/lessee. His Publican's License was granted on 17 October 1890. With the general economy in ruins, George's Buy/Lease advertisements were getting no takers, & almost a year later in Sep 1891,
"Como Hotel" owner/publican George & his wife were successfully sued by Tooth & Co. for a bounced cheque, being fined ''"£5 and costs, in default one month's imprisonment"''. Finally, on 25 September 1891 (almost 14 months after George's first Buy/Lease advertisement), a notice in
the Australian Star newspaper listed George Agnew had transferred his Publican's License to a new Lessee & publican, Mr. Daniel Sullivan, thus signaling a tumultuous period for the "Como Hotel" involving rapid turnover of owners/Licensees (see the partial Timeline below for more detail). By the time Paul Buchholz had bought out the License on 16 February 1905, he had become the 12th Licensee in only 13½ years (exclusive of the 1st owner/Licensee, George Agnew). In 1983, the "Como Hotel" was purchased by a unit trust company headed by Mr. Russell Coshott, who planned to "restore & upgrade the Hotel" by subdividing & selling as residential lots the adjoining two acres of freehold land. However, the plan was blocked by vehement local opposition. On 16 July 1984, it was reported in the Sydney Morning Herald that
"The elegant old Como Hotel, described as an Australian version of a Victorian period seaside pleasure palace, has been protected by a Heritage Council anti-demolition order. The four-story white stucco, brick and timber hotel in Cremona Road at the southern end of the Como railway bridge has been a landmark of the Georges River foreshores since the 1880s. In recent weeks controversy has raged in the Como community about plans by the owners to erect a four-story building of 42 flats and a carpark behind the hotel. The plans have been opposed by local resident and environmental groups. Sutherland Shire Council recently rejected the development application on several grounds. These included that the flats would have a detrimental impact on the scenic quality of the locality". (footnote – the article is mistaken in stating this version of the Como Hotel was Established in the 1880s – it should read from 1890). Unfortunately, on 3 November 1996, the
"Como Hotel" was ravaged by fire as a result of an unattended gas cooker in the restaurant kitchen.
Timeline 1888–1923 • 30 March 1888 – Notice of Application was made in the Daily Telegraph (Sydney) by George Agnew for a Conditional Publican's License
"for a house to be erected at Como, Georges River, containing 16 rooms exclusive of those required for the use of the family, and in accordance with the plans lodged with the Licensing Clerk, Sydney". This was for plans to either completely re-build his existing more modestly-sized
"Como Hotel" or for approval to build a completely new larger structure, where the current version now stands. • 18 April 1888 – George Agnew was granted a Conditional License
"for an hotel at Como". Following the re-build/new construction, this new
"Como Hotel" would go on to serve as the German workers' club throughout the duplication of railway lines and construction of the dual rail bridge. However, it still had to survive a rocky first few years of business, with the Lease passing through the hands of numerous Licensees. • 15 January 1889 – George Agnew, licensee, ''"was fined £5 and costs, in default one month's imprisonment, for having committed a breach of the Licensing Act in selling liquor on a Sunday"''. • 17 December 1889 – Multiple Tenders are invited by building contractor R. Fielding for
"carting building materials from Como siding, Illawarra line, to back of Como Station",
"Quarrying a large quantity of Stone, at Como, near station, Illawarra line" &
"for 160,000 Bricks, delivered Como station, Illawarra line." This is all preparatory for the new build of the "Como Hotel". • 12 February 1890 – Multiple Tenders are invited by building contractor Robert Fielding for
"Plumbing of large Hotel at Como Station",
"Plastering, &c., of large Hotel at Como Station" &
"for a large quantity of Iron Columns, Balcony Railings, Ornamental Castings, &c., for large Hotel, Como". The completion of the new building work would have been circa early 1890, with a few more months for final equipping & fitting out. • 9 July 1890 – The first Leasing advertisement is placed by agents W.H. Tulloh (on behalf of proprietor George Agnew) for ''"The new COMO HOTEL, COMO, Southern line, great holiday resort, grand shooting and fishing, the place for wedding parties, picnics, and holiday-makers generally; no other such chance offering anywhere. Duplication of railway line in immediate vicinity will give 800 men employment for possibly 18 months. Immediate possession, 12 years' lease, just built. Only principals"''. • 9 October 1890 – George Agnew makes an Application for a Conditional Publican's license for his new 20 room hotel at Como. • 14 October 1890 – With no success in finding a suitable Lessee after 3 months, a further Let/Lease advertisement is placed by agents W.H. Tulloh (on behalf of proprietor George Agnew) for the
"COMO HOTEL, Como. Splendidly situated for holiday requirements; just finished regardless of expense every convenience, grand rooms, public and private bars, cellar unsurpassed, to be LET or LEASE, moderate terms; furnished or unfurnished; OR the property itself can be bought right out. Grand opportunity for sporting men with good connection". • 17 October 1890 – A Conditional Publican's license is granted to George Agnew "for premises at Como". • 10 September 1891 – A Court proceedings article in the Evening News reports that ''"Tooth and Co., brewers, George-street, sued George Agnew, of Como, George's River, licensed publican, and his wife, for the recovery of £26 1s. 3d, amount due with interest on a promissory note, made by the female defendant, dated July 4, 1889, and dishonored. A verdict was given for the amount claimed with costs of three witnesses."'' • 25 September 1891 – Approximately 14 months had elapsed following the first Lease advertisement for the new
"Como Hotel" before a notice in the Australian Star listed George Agnew transferring his License to the new Lessee & publican, Mr Daniel Sullivan. • 5 December 1891 – New publican Dan Sullivan (late of Brisbane) advertised that he had opened the fully refurbished, no expense spared
"Como Hotel",
"It has no superior outside Sydney, and the Accommodation cannot be surpassed",
"There is no Healthier Place in the Colony". • 21 May 1892 – An advertisement was placed by Assigned Estate agents T.M. Hall for
"Tenders for the Stock, Furniture, Goodwill, License, &c., of the Como Hotel (Illawarra Line)" The hospitality business for publican Dan Sullivan was clearly struggling, as he was close to Bankruptcy. • 22 June 1892 – An Auction advertisement for the Assigned Estate of Daniel Sullivan was placed by agent T.M. Hall for
"The whole of the FURNITURE, and EFFECTS of the COMO HOTEL, to be sold by auction upon the premises, Como, MONDAY, June 27." Shortly after the auction, Charles Martin Buck come into legal possession of the Hotel to the exclusion of licensee Daniel Sullivan. • 22 July 1892 – An advertisement in the Australian Star newspaper shows a new hotel publican, George William Cubbon, had received the License for the
"Como Hotel" from short-term de facto licensee Charles Martin Buck. • 30 July 1892 – An advertisement was placed by new licensee George Cubbon for the opening under new management of the
"Como Hotel". • 9 August 1892 – The aged skeleton of an unidentified young female was discovered by the night officer in charge of Como Station, Mr George Morris, "about 300 yards from Como Station, and about the same distance from the Como Hotel, where the skeleton now lies. This is the second skeleton found under the same rock within less than a month." The bones were laid "on the table of Mr. Cubbon's hotel bar parlor" for the Police to inspect. In August an inquest for both skeletons found the female had been killed by a bullet to the left side of her skull & that a male aboriginal had been killed by unknown means. The
"coroner returned an open verdict in accordance with the evidence". • 21 October 1892 – A notice in the Evening News (Sydney) listed G.W. Cubbon had transferred his License to the publican, Mr John S. Gregory. • 17 February 1893 – A notice in the Evening News (Sydney) listed John S. Gregory had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Charles H. Forwood. • 20 December 1893 – In the Referee (Sydney) it is reported that Licensee Charles Forwood wishes to organize a shooting match in Como
"Como is just in the centre of a good shooting district, and I am certain a prettier spot could scarcely be looked for out of Sydney. Mr Forwood will probably visit the Gun Club grounds next Friday for the purpose of interviewing shooters." • 1 February 1894 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Charles H. Forwood had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Charles Nicholson. • 18 December 1894 – A Court proceedings article in The Australian Star (Sydney) reports
"Sub-inspector Elliott proceeded against Charles Nicholson, licensee of the Como Hotel, Como, at the Newtown Court, yesterday, on a charge of having sold liquor on Sunday, December 9. A fine of £3 was imposed. The defendant was also fined 10s. for having permitted music on his premises." • 5 September 1895 – A Licensing Court notice in the Daily Telegraph (Sydney) listed Charles Nicholson had transferred his License to new publican, Mr John Thomson. However, Mr Thomson fell ill. • 24 October 1895 – A Licensing Court notice in the Australian Star (Sydney) listed Charles Buck (in lieu Mr Thomson) had transferred the License to new publican, Mr Henry (aka Harry) A. Brett. • 25 March 1897 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Henry (aka Harry) Arthur Brett had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Sidney Mortimer Staples. • 15 March 1898 – Funeral notice for Mr John Thomson, formerly of the Como Hotel. • 15 July 1898 – An Auction advertisement was placed by agent C.W. Maddocks & Co. for
"The LEASE, LICENSE, GOODWILL, and FURNITURE" of the Como Hotel." • 13 October 1898 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Sidney Mortimer Staples had been granted a renewal of his publican's license for the Como Hotel. • 24 February 1900 – A Court proceedings article in the Sydney Morning Herald reports ''"Sidney M. Staples, licensee of the Como Hotel, Como, was charged with having between 1 and 2.30 p.m. on Sunday, Feb 11, kept his licensed premises open for the sale of liquor. Defendant was fined £3 and costs 5s 6d, in default 7 days' gaol."'' • 2 July 1903 – A Licensing Court notice in the Australian Star (Sydney) listed S.M. Staples had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Dominic Joseph Trim. • 12 September 1903 – A Licensing Court notice in the South Coast Times (Wollongongy) listed S.M. Staples had transferred his License to new publican, Mr J. Pauchon. • 16 February 1905 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed J. Pauchon had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Paul Buchholz. This signaled a brief period of licensee stability for the next 8 years. • 3 October 1913 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Paul Buchholz had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Ernest Hope-Caten of South Africa. • 17 July 1914 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Ernest Hope-Caten had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Donald O'Donnell. • 11 March 1916 – An auction notice for the sale of the entire going concern of the "Como Hotel" appeared in the Sydney Morning Herald However, on 18 March 1916 it was noted that the "Como Hotel" was passed in at the auction, failing to sell at the reserve of £2,200. Clearly, the business conditions for owning an Hotel midway during the First World War had deteriorated. • 11 July 1919 – Finally, a Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald indicates Donald O'Donnell was successful in transferring the License to new owner Edward Cliffe. • 3 February 1920 – A Police Court notice in the Daily Telegraph (Sydney) reports that the licensee Edward Cliffe was fined for illegal Sunday trading. • 28 October 1921 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Edward Cliffe had transferred his License to new publican, Mr Alexander Lumb. • 7 April 1922 – A Court notice in the St George Call notes licensee Sydney Watkins had been fined for illegal Sunday trading. • 30 March 1923 – A Licensing Court notice in the Sydney Morning Herald listed Sydney Watkins had transferred his License to new publican, Mr David Thomas. The rapid turnover of licensees for the Como Hotel continued for many years thereafter.
More recent developments The existing "third" version of the
"Como Hotel" was constructed five years after the second version had been destroyed by fire in 1996, with the rebuild (on the same site) completed in 2001, officially re-opened in 3 November 2001. It featured a modern but sympathetic interpretation of the 2nd version's Edwardian design – the new restaurant was aptly named "The Burnt Door," & it displays at its centre the charred remains of one of the hotel's doors which had been salvaged from the ashes of the inferno. In early 2013, the current 3rd version of the "Como Hotel", located at 35 Cremona Road, sold for $4.6 million on a yield of 14.4% to the Riversdale Group. Towards the end of 2016, the Riversdale Group sold the "Como Hotel" for $5.6 million to the Oscars Hotel Group.
Establishment date clarification The current (3rd) version of the
"Como Hotel" bears an Establishment date (applied during 2001 construction) on the upper facades of
"1878". However, all the publicly available research shows this is clearly incorrect. With the locality of
"Como" not even coming into existence until early mid-1883 & the fact(s) that the original 1st version of the
"Como Hotel" was
not even completed construction until January 1887, nor was the second version construction completed until
early 1890, the currently displayed date of "1878" is clearly wrong. This has led to many other less comprehensively researched articles regarding the
"Como Hotel" quoting the historically incorrect Establishment date of
"1878", rather than what should be the factual Establishment date of
"1890" (also confirmed by a vintage photo circa 1894 of the second version's facade). ==Transport==