Food critics recommend reservations, noting that the restaurant is often full at lunch, especially on Fridays. Similarly, Mariana Camacho from
The Infatuation added that reservations are often made months in advance due to the restaurant's popularity. Ana Paula Tovar of
El País recommended the
meringue with strawberries or fig tart for dessert. Critics have praised the tuna tostada, describing it as "well-executed", "iconic", and a "must-try" dish. Contramar and Cala in
San Francisco, both owned by Cámara, are the subject of the 2019
Netflix documentary
A Tale of Two Kitchens. Regarding the experience of opening a sister restaurant in the United States, she said: "Opening a Mexican restaurant in the United States is a paradox no matter how you look at it [...] there is a lot of curiosity and respect for authentic Mexican food. On the other hand, there is a larger culture that despises Mexicans". Contramar received in 2019 the Best Dining Room Service award from the
México Gastronómico guide and Best Service in Mexico from
Travel + Leisure magazine. In 2023, Contramar was voted the tenth best international restaurant by
Food & Wine magazine readers. It received a
Bib Gourmand from the
Michelin Guide in 2025; the inspectors described the spot as enchanting and recommended the . == See also ==