The album was generally well received.
AllMusic praised the album for being something new while still being familiar to Patrick's past with Filter and
Nine Inch Nails, describing it as "Less politically on the nose than the poppy
Anthems for the Damned, more mature than the easy retread of
The Trouble with Angels, and more visceral than
The Sun Comes Out Tonight" and ultimately that "
Crazy Eyes manages to tread new ground for Filter while respectfully acknowledging the sound that propelled the band in the first place. The Sputnik Music staff review echoes these sentiments, stating that the album was better than Filter's last few albums, but that "though harder to digest on a first listen, these songs gradually get under your skin, revealing one of Filter's greatest LPs to date." Renowned for Sound was less positive about the album, criticizing Patrick's rough vocals and concluding that "Patrick tries to cover too much ground on one record, creating the feeling of a collection of songs instead of the feeling of an album. Had
Crazy Eyes featured a unity of purpose, the great songs on the record could have been extended to making a great album. ==Track listing==