Bias towards popular shows Since its inception, the Crunchyroll Anime Awards have been criticized for its process in nominations and awarding. Its
inaugural ceremony in 2017, saw allegations of possible voting fraud after the sports series
Yuri on Ice won all of its seven nominations including
Anime of the Year. The win caused a controversy among Crunchyroll users, who accused fans of the series for rigging the vote in a heavily aggressive campaign. Following this, Crunchyroll responded by adjusting the awards system, introducing a new weighting system favoring jury in an attempt to minimize the effect of popular shows sweeping the awards. This change stopped the extremely popular superhero series
My Hero Academia from unexpectedly losing the Anime of the Year to
Made in Abyss in the
following edition. The bias towards popular shows have been noted by several publications, including those who are part of the jury itself. In a reflection piece after the
8th edition,
Animehunch opined that due to its design, the awards favor popularity over merit, noting that the
second season of
Vinland Saga was a far better recipient of Anime of the Year than the
second season of
Jujutsu Kaisen. This is reflected again in the following edition, where the extremely popular anime adaptation of the
manhwa series
Solo Leveling won the Anime of the Year over critically-acclaimed series ''
Frieren: Beyond Journey's End and The Apothecary Diaries''. The decision led some viewers to question whether the awards were prioritizing
hype and
recency bias over artistic merit. Meanwhile, despite receiving 16 nominations,
Netflix's
Delicious in Dungeon did not win a single award. This outcome led to speculation about a potential bias against non-Crunchyroll platforms, with many fans questioning whether the series was deliberately overlooked, though
Devilman Crybaby and
Cyberpunk: Edgerunners, both released on Netflix, won the award in
2019 and
2023 respectively.
Lack of diversity in nominations The lack of diversity in the nominations was also criticized: 29 of the 32 award winners were works whose originals were published in
Weekly Shōnen Jump; of the nine voice acting categories, four went to voice actors who voiced
Denji from
Chainsaw Man, while only one female voice actress won an award: she voiced
Power from the same series. In an article in the
This Week in Anime section on
Anime News Network, in which editors Steve Jones and Nicholas Dupree had a sarcastic argument, they concluded that this award show was not for animators or translators, but for the bosses who collect the revenue from the franchises. In this context, the award for the second season of
Jujutsu Kaisen was viewed critically in various categories, as the animation studio had been criticized in the past for its poor working conditions. == See also ==