Original Broadway production The producers
Frederick Brisson, Robert E. Griffith and Harold S. Prince had decided that the lead actress for the part of "Lola" had to be a dancer. They offered the role to both the movie actress
Mitzi Gaynor and ballet dancer
Zizi Jeanmaire, each of whom turned down the role. Although
Gwen Verdon had sung just one song in her previous show (
Can-Can), the producers were willing to take a chance on her. She initially refused, preferring to assist another choreographer, but finally agreed. Choreographer
Bob Fosse insisted on meeting her before working with her, and after meeting and working for a brief time, they each agreed to the arrangement. This was the start of an artistic and personal partnership between Fosse and Verdon, who married in 1960. The show opened on
Broadway at the
46th Street Theatre on May 5, 1955, transferred to the
Adelphi Theatre on May 17, 1957, and ran for a total of 1,019 performances. It was directed by
George Abbott, with scenery and costumes by
William and Jean Eckart, dances and musical numbers staged by Fosse, musical direction by Hal Hastings, orchestrations by
Don Walker, and dance music arrangements by Roger Adams. The show starred
Ray Walston (Applegate), Verdon (Lola),
Shannon Bolin (Meg), Robert Shafer (Joe Boyd), Elizabeth Howell (Doris),
Stephen Douglass (Joe Hardy), Al Lanti (Henry), Eddie Phillips (Sohovik), Nathaniel Frey (Smokey), Albert Linville (Vernon, Postmaster),
Russ Brown (Van Buren),
Jimmy Komack (Rocky),
Rae Allen (Gloria), Cherry Davis (Teenager), Del Horstmann (Lynch, Commissioner), Richard Bishop (Welch), Janie Janvier (Miss Weston), and
Jean Stapleton (Sister).
Original West End production A
West End production played at the
London Coliseum beginning on March 28, 1957, where it played for 258 performances. It starred Olympic skater
Belita (aka Gladys Lyne Jepson-Turner) as Lola, but the Fosse choreography was alien to her style, and she was replaced by
Elizabeth Seal. It also starred
Bill Kerr as Applegate, and
Ivor Emmanuel as Joe Hardy. In the mid-1970s,
Vincent Price starred as Applegate in summer stock productions of the show. In the late 1970s and early 1980s film actor
Van Johnson did so in productions throughout the U.S.A. In July, 1981, a production was performed at the
Jones Beach Marine Theater in
Wantagh, New York. It was notable due to former
New York Jets quarterback
Joe Namath being cast in the role of Joe Boyd.
Broadway revival A Broadway revival opened at the
Marquis Theatre on March 3, 1994 and ran for 519 performances and 33 previews. Featured were
Jarrod Emick as Joe Hardy, winner of the 1994 Tony Award for Best Featured Actor in a Musical,
Bebe Neuwirth as Lola and
Victor Garber as Applegate. Garber was succeeded by
Jerry Lewis, making his Broadway debut, on March 12, 1995, who then starred in a national tour and also played the role in a London production.
Jack O'Brien directed, with choreography by
Rob Marshall, assisted by his sister,
Kathleen. O'Brien is also credited with revisions to the book.
North Shore Music Theatre In 2006,
North Shore Music Theatre in
Beverly, Massachusetts, presented a revised production with the
Washington Senators replaced with the Yankees' traditional rivals, the
Boston Red Sox. The revised book was written, with permission, by
Joe DiPietro.
Reprise! Broadway's Best In 2007,
Reprise! Broadway's Best produced a revival.
Jason Alexander directed, resetting the show to 1981 Los Angeles and making changes to accommodate a largely African-American and Hispanic cast. It opened November 7, 2007 and ran through November 25.
Encores! A revival was produced by the
City Center Encores! Summer Stars series from July 5 to July 27, 2008. It starred
Jane Krakowski as Lola,
Sean Hayes as Applegate,
Randy Graff as Meg,
Megan Lawrence as Gloria Thorpe (replacing an injured
Ana Gasteyer during rehearsal),
P. J. Benjamin as Joe Boyd, and
Cheyenne Jackson as Joe Hardy.
John Rando directed and the original Fosse choreography was reproduced by Mary MacLeod. Given the substantial changes in the 1994 revival, this is considered by some the first authentic revival of the original production.
Off-Broadway benefit performance A one-night-only
off-Broadway benefit performance was staged by
Roundabout Theatre Company. The benefit, which was directed by
Kathleen Marshall, occurred on December 11, 2017. It starred
Stephen Bogardus as Joe Boyd,
Matthew Morrison as Joe Hardy,
Victoria Clark as Meg,
Maggie Gyllenhaal as Lola,
Whoopi Goldberg as a
gender-bent Applegate,
Danny Burstein as Van Buren, and
Adrienne Warren as Gloria. It was produced by Scott Landis,
Jerry Frankel, and Jay and Cindy Gutterman.
Arena Stage production From 9 September to 9 November 2025,
Arena Stage presented a revised production of the show with a new book by
Will Power and
Doug Wright, and new additional lyrics by
Lynn Ahrens.
Sergio Trujillo directed and choreographed the production in the round in Arena's Fischandler Theater. The cast was led by
Rob McClure as Applegate and
Jordan Donica as Joe Hardy, with
Ana Villafañe as Lola,
Quentin Earl Darrington as Joe Boyd, Bryonha Marie as Meg Boyd, Alysha Umphress as Gloria Thorpe, Nehal Joshi as Van Buren, Keenan McCarter as Welch, Rayanne Gonzales as Sister, and Sarah Anne Sillers as Doris. The revised production, set during the
New York Yankees 2000 championship run, is being helmed by lead producer
Haley Swindal, the theater-loving granddaughter of former Yankee's owner
George Steinbrenner. Swindal is soliciting investors to bring the production to Broadway. The production is aiming for a spring 2027 opening on Broadway. ==Musical numbers==