Computer Gaming World called
Dark Seed in 1992 "the most integrated and effective feel for a horror adventure yet" but criticized the unforgiving real-time gameplay that often caused unwinnable situations, hard-to-find on-screen puzzle elements, and an overly abrupt ending, stating that "the interactive elements are so poorly implemented that they nearly destroy the effect" of the graphics and sound. The magazine nonetheless concluded that the game "hint[s] at tremendous potential" and hoped that Cyberdreams' future games would be "not only beautiful, but fun to play".
QuestBusters recommended the game to fans of the
Alien films and
Accolade's
Elvira games. The reviewer wrote: "The graphics are impressive, the atmosphere gripping, but for me the staying power was the story and wondering what was going to happen next", and concluded: "I didn't think it was the best thing out this year, but I certainly would have missed out if I'd passed it by. Give it a shot". The game was reviewed in 1992 in
Dragon #188 by Hartley, Patricia, and Kirk Lesser in "The Role of Computers" column. The reviewers gave the game 3 out of 5 stars.
Amiga Format gave the Amiga version of
Dark Seed an overall score of 72%, praising the use of Giger's artwork and "stunningly spooky" graphics, calling it "the nearest thing you could have to a software nightmare", but criticizes its strict timeframe, and refers to ''Dark Seed's
gameplay as "its weakest element". Rob Lawrence of Amiga World wrote that the graphics, art, and sound of Dark Seed'' were good, but only "skin-deep." He thought the game was ultimately too small and linear, and that the ending was "stupid".
Next Generation gave the Sega CD version (which was ultimately never released) three out of five stars, describing it as "a perfect example of graphic-adventure-as-nightmare ... Half of the game's appeal lies in the bizarre and frightening hallucinations suffered by the hero (or maybe they aren't hallucinations...). We recommend checking it out". In 1993, the game received a
Codie award from the
Software Publishers Association for Best Fantasy Role-Playing/Adventure.
Dark Seed was a nominee for
Computer Games Strategy Pluss 1992 "Best Adventure" award, which ultimately went to
The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel. The magazine's Theo Clarke wrote: "The strength of this game lies in its atmosphere, but my pleasure was diminished by the use of a master diskette at the security device". ==Legacy==