Upon its release,
Darkwatch received generally favorable reviews from most gaming media. According to review aggregation site GameTab, the PlayStation 2 version scored an averaged rating of 82% from the gaming press with the Xbox version scoring 85%. It also won several art direction and visual design awards, including five Davey Awards and a Telly Award. The game received the score of 7.9 ("Good") from both Bob Colayco of
GameSpot ("If you're looking for an intense shooter experience,
Darkwatch will not disappoint") and Jeremy Dunham of
IGN ("Cowboys, vampires, and sexy dead girls are fun in parties, but not so much alone"). John Scalzo of Gaming Target wrote that "for anyone looking for something a little different out of their
FPS experience,
Darkwatch is that game". The reviewer in
GamePro wrote that
Darkwatch "mixes its western roots with
gothic horror and
steampunk aesthetics, and the results are uniquely engaging", adding that if some the game's "cooler" concepts "had been explored further, lengthening the game in the process,
Darkwatch could've rivaled the best of the genre". Several reviews praised the game's setting.
GameSpy's David Chapman called it "a truly remarkable experience. And, while the game itself may not have broken any new ground, the world it introduces more than makes up for that. It will leave gamers hungry for more". On the other hand, some reviews thought that the gameplay was actually the strongest part of the game.
Official UK PlayStation 2 Magazine stated that
Darkwatch "has a few neat ideas but wins us over by doing solid shooting well. Fast-paced with cool guns, what's not to like?"
GameZones Mike David wrote that only a "weak plot pacing and that feeling that something is missing" kept it from being given a score of 9/10.
Eurogamers Martin Coxall called it "a generic and quickly tiresome shooter, with a contrived premise which, unfortunately, does nothing to elevate it". In a 2012 article about the history of steampunk video games, Mike Mahardy of
Game Informer wrote that "although not a widely known shooter,
Darkwatch garnered a
cult following with its unique story and unusual setting". That same year, Robert Workman of
Comic Book Resources called
Darkwatch "in particular [...] a fantastic effort, a first-person shooter with beautiful, spooky atmosphere and excellent gameplay". In 2013,
Metro included it among the "games that didn't get the love they deserved". Mark L. Bussler of
Classic Game Room said in a retro video review that among many shooters on the PlayStation 2, "few are as fun as this", adding that
Darkwatch should be "in your collection" alongside
Red Faction and
TimeSplitters.
FEARNET included it among their five favorite vampire games in 2014. ==Legacy==