Gill stated that "fortifying the border" would be his principal policy objective. He supports mass
deportations. He has also described "
remigration" policies as "desperately needed". At an event hosted by the
New York Young Republican Club, Gill praised
Daniel Penny, who was acquitted of manslaughter for the
killing of Jordan Neely. Gill said, "I think we need a lot more Daniel Pennys in this country, because we have far too many Jordan Neelys." According to
MSNBC's Jared Holt, Gill celebrated Penny's acquittal on
X by posting "
It's still not illegal to be white." Gill supports President Trump's proposal to redevelop the
Gaza Strip, stating "President Trump is bringing peace to the Middle East, just as he promised. PROMISES KEPT."
Islam Gill has made a series of remarks characterized as
Islamophobic. The
Washington Post reported that Gill made comments "similar" to those by Rep.
Randy Fine and Sen.
Tommy Tuberville that the paper characterized as "blatant Islamophobia". In June 2025, Gill commented on a video of New York City mayoral candidate
Zohran Mamdani eating with his hands, "Civilized people in America don't eat like this. If you refuse to adopt Western customs, go back to the Third World." Gill later criticized Mamdani for releasing a campaign video in
Arabic, writing "Just a couple decades after
9/11, the leading candidate for NYC mayor is campaigning in Arabic. The humiliation is the point." In October 2025, Gill responded to journalist
Mehdi Hasan on
X, stating that Muslims were moving to the U.S. "en masse" to "fundamentally transform the landscape of American public life," and telling Hasan, "If you want to live in a Muslim country, go back to the UK." In a
Newsmax interview, Gill said that "Islam is a political ideology that is incompatible with the United States. It's incompatible with our constitutional system and with Western civilization more broadly." Gill called for the restriction of
Muslim immigration to the United States. Gill repeated his claim that Islam was incompatible with the United States in his newsletter, writing “How many times do we have to hear 'Allahu Akbar' in America before we recognize Islam is a problem?”In February 2026, Gill wrote on social media "How many Americans have to get ‘Allahu Akbar’ed before we realize Islam is a problem?” Gill claimed that his constituents were "desperately concerned about the Islamization of the Dallas area." Gill said that "When you hear about constituents talking about going to their local malls and you look around and it feels like you're in
Pakistan, not Dallas, Texas, that's a problem." In March 2026, Gill called for a total ban on Muslim immigration to the United States, writing "No more Muslims immigrating to America." {{cite news|last=Sprunt|first=Barbara|title=House GOP leadership silent as more members post anti-Muslim statements ==Electoral history==