Farmhouse burglary In December 2009, an amount of cash was stolen from Mabuza's farmhouse in Mpumalanga. The story attracted attention in part because it was never clearly established how much money was stolen. The
Sunday Times heard from several police sources that
R14 million was stolen, but that only R4 million had been reported missing "because it would have raised eyebrows that the premier kept such a large amount of money at a residential property". In November 2010, a police
constable confirmed that a case had been opened at the
Barberton police station regarding R4 million; it had been referred to the
organised crime unit because it was a high-profile case.
Lawsuit against Mathews Phosa In 2014, Mabuza unsuccessfully sued his former boss, Mathews Phosa, for
defamation. The suit concerned a document entitled
Classified: Top Secret! Reports of a Police Agent which Mabuza said Phosa had published and circulated in the
ANC. Mabuza said that the document made various incorrect and defamatory claims, including that Mabuza was a spy for the apartheid
police from 1985 to 1993. Phosa said that he had seen the document and had forwarded it to
ANC Deputy Secretary General
Jessie Duarte, but denied involvement in its publication. In August 2018, in a lengthy exposé, the
New York Times reported that while Premier Mabuza had built a network of political
patronage in
Mpumalanga by artificially inflating, and carefully distributing, contracts to build schools in the province – a strategy facilitated by his Rapid Implementation Unit – and thereby strengthened his political base at the expense of the public service delivery. He said that the various allegations against him are part of a
smear campaign by his opponents.
Alleged political violence Mabuza was rumoured to have been involved in
political violence in Mpumalanga. This includes persistent rumours, particularly among his local political opponents, that, while Premier, Mabuza was involved in conspiracies which led to
political killings in the province. Mabuza was linked to the assassination of Sammy Mpatlanyane, a government official who was shot in 2010 after he refused to sign off on controversial tenders. Most prominently, however, he was frequently linked to the assassination of Jimmy Mohlala, who was shot dead on 4 January 2009. Mohlala was the
Speaker of
Mbombela Municipality and had launched a "crusade" against
tender corruption related to the construction of the Mbombela Stadium; his murder was viewed as an attempt to
cover up the corruption. Controversial activist
James Nkambule, of the
Congress of the People, claimed publicly that Mabuza was responsible; he also accused Mabuza of using state resources to intimidate him, and reported him to the police for intimidation over a threatening SMS he claimed Mabuza had sent him. Nkambule claimed to have met a
Mozambican man named
'Josh' said he had been hired to murder Mohlala and others, and he was lobbying for the man's entrance into
witness protection when he was poisoned in October 2010. Several years later, Mabuza's former
butler, Jan Venter, alleged that Mabuza had once "let slip" to him that he was behind the assassinations of "Jimmy and James", which Venter understood as a reference to Mohlala and Nkambule; Venter was put in witness protection. In addition,
Mzilikazi wa Afrika, a
Sunday Times journalist who reported extensively on the killings and the claims of the alleged hitman, was arrested in August 2010 on a forgery charge laid by Mabuza, later dropped.''' In 2014, two men from Mbombela claimed that they had been members of a "
dirty tricks" task team formed by Mabuza to suppress allegations that he was involved in political killings; they had been offered R3 million and jobs in the government and had been instructed to steal documents from Nkabule. Mabuza consistently denied involvement in the assassinations, and, as of 2022, the allegations had never been prosecuted or proven. In 2016, he told a journalist, "One day, people will get clarity when they lay hands on privileged information I have about the political murders... This individual bought people to kill people and allege that I killed them. They wanted me arrested... to be out of the way." He said the "private army" carried weapons, disrupted ANC meetings, and otherwise sought to intimidate local ANC members who did not support Mabuza's political agenda. He made the allegation in connection with a video that had surfaced of gunmen firing shots recklessly at a gathering, apparently in Mpumalanga; Phosa said that the men were connected to Mabuza. At the time, Phosa was instituting a court challenge against the Mpumalanga ANC, believing that there had been improper conduct in the process by which it had nominated candidates for election at the 54th National Conference. == Philanthropy ==