Contemporary response Dawn of the Dead received generally positive reviews upon its release, with critics praising it as a worthy remake of the original and a fine addition to the zombie genre. Audiences polled by
CinemaScore reported that moviegoers gave the film an average
letter grade of B. The film was considered by most to be an improvement over the original in terms of acting, production values, and scares, Despite giving it a negative review,
Variety said that the film was "more palatable" than the "atrocious"
Texas Chainsaw Massacre remake of the previous year. a sentiment also shared by
IGN. while
Roger Ebert said in a positive review that anyone paying to see it is guaranteed to get their money's worth. Abundant praise was given to the film's opening sequence, which, for an otherwise negative review on
The Hollywood Reporter, was "pulse-poundingly good". Gingold found Snyder's camerawork using a
first-person video-game perspective at the beginning of the film to be praiseworthy, more so than those of the live-action videogame adaptations
Resident Evil (2002) and
House of the Dead (2003). and could pass for a remake of the original, by contrast.
Wesley Morris gave a negative review in which he said the film "feels like the product of the
PlayStation era" as opposed to a reverence for Romero. Conversely, the
BBC complimented the film as a "stylish, gore-drenched shoot-em-up", In a 2024 interview with
The Hollywood Reporter, Pegg described the remake as a "great movie", but criticized Snyder's decision to stick with the title
Dawn of the Dead, saying, "They could have called it
Deadish, which was a great line in the film that one of the actors used, and it still would have been a great film, but when you just take a title because people recognize it, it's so disrespectful to the original." Numerous publications have named
Dawn of the Dead Snyder's best film. Revisiting the film on its 15th anniversary in 2019, Joe Lipsett wrote the following verdict for
Bloody Disgusting: Fifteen years later,
Dawn of the Dead completely holds up. The film's flaws are mostly at the character level, though having a dumb zombie baby and a few undeveloped red shirts in the mix is hardly a deal breaker. The action – particularly the opening scene and the
propane explosion climax – in addition to the fantastic special effects makeup, the brief flirtation with
found footage, and the reverence for its source text while introducing something new makes 2004's
Dawn of the Dead one of the best remakes on the market. In a June 2018 article for
The Hollywood Reporter, Richard Newby wrote that
Dawn of the Dead helped revitalize the zombie genre along with
28 Days Later at a time when the United States "was ripe for the re-emergence of zombie movies" following the
September 11 attacks, which he believes to have contributed to the Americans' "increased fear of
biological weapons, fervent mass
militarization and the burrowing question of who exactly are the people we call our neighbors". Author
Stephen King, in the forenote of the 2010 edition of his book
Danse Macabre, saw what he believed to be Snyder's subtext conveying the horrors induced by terrorist attacks, drawing parallels between the zombie apocalypse and a post-9/11 America. King described
Dawn of the Dead as "genius perfected" in terms of its standing in the zombie genre.
South Park creators
Trey Parker and
Matt Stone and South Korean filmmaker
Yeon Sang-ho have also spoken of their appreciation of
Dawn of the Dead and cited its influence upon their works. ,
Dawn of the Dead is Snyder's highest-rated film on the website, where it has also made its lists of The 20 Scariest Opening Scenes in Horror Movie History (at number 6), The 25 Best Horror Movie Remakes (at number 9), The 30 Essential Zombie Movies (at number 13), and 18 Memorable Horror Remakes.
Dawn of the Dead has made several rankings of the top zombie films, including number 3 by
Rolling Stone (2012), number 12 by
Empire (2020), by
Collider (2021), number 17 by
IndieWire (2022), and by
Variety (2023); as well as the best horror films, including number 3 by
Dread Central (2010), number 8 by Bloody Disgusting (2009), number 52 by
IGN, and number 55 by
Rolling Stone (2020).
Accolades ==Spiritual successor==