Variety gave the film a positive review, calling the picture "a handsomely mounted independent production, that abounds in dignity, restraint and distinction." They enjoyed the fictionalized account of the life of Christ, which they felt did not contain many of the "familiar embellishments" often found in biblical films. They complimented Pichel's direction; called Cobb's performance "forceful and shrewd"; said Dru gave a "touching performance"; and Griffith was "bitingly realistic". They particularly highlighted the performance of Wilson as Jesus, calling his portrayal, "humble, saintly and reverent". They also enjoyed the work of Gilmore, Warde, and Freud. They also gave good marks to Ray June's camera-work, Thomas Neff's editing, Daniele Amfitheatrof's music, as well as the production elements of Friedrich. The
Tyler-Courier-Times-Telegraph also gave the film a good review, calling it a "remarkable blending of the straight Gospel with the history of the era in which Jesus lived, as set forth by the foremost historians of the day."
The Los Angeles Times also gave the film a good review, declaring it was a "forcefully told story...rich in inspirational and human values". They also complimented the screenplay in handling several delicate issues in such an adept fashion so as to not offend any particular religious group. They also praised June's cinematography and Amfitheatrof's score, as well as the directing of Pichel. Among the cast, they congratulated Dru, Cobb, McVey, Connors, Gilmore, Freud, Glass, Whitney, Ward, and Gerry. ==References==