Death Becomes Her received mixed reviews from critics, who praised its special effects and lead performances, but some found it lacking depth and substance. Review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes gives the film an approval rating of 58% based on 59 reviews, with an average rating of 6/10. The site's critics consensus reads: "Hawn and Streep are as fabulous as
Death Becomes Hers innovative special effects; Zemeckis's satire, on the other hand, is as hollow as the world it mocks." On
Metacritic, the film has a
weighted average score of 56 out of 100 based on 24 critics, indicating "mixed or average" reviews. Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B" on an A+ to F scale. The
Chicago Tribune's
Dave Kehr wrote, "Instantly grotesque, relentless misanthropic and spectacularly tasteless, 'Death Becomes Her' isn't a film designed to win the hearts of the mass moviegoing public. But it is diabolically inventive and very, very funny."
Todd McCarthy of
Variety said, "While the fountain of youth theme has often come up in films, it has never been given anything like this treatment before."
People praised the film's "flashes of originality, brilliant special effects and terrific performances—Willis as a curdled Milquetoast and Hawn as a woman who is finally feeling her own power. Streep makes a fine untamed shrew, by turns shrill, whiny and cooing". Willis was also singled out for his
against type comedic performance.
Gene Siskel and
Roger Ebert both gave
Death Becomes Her a 'thumbs down', commenting that while the film has great special effects, it lacks any real substance or character depth.
People said "screenwriters David Koepp and Martin Donovan would have done well to keep their skewed, scabrous vision in sharper focus and to display satire that rises to the level of a scene in which Rossellini is throwing a party for her myriad clients". Rita Kempley of
The Washington Post gave an overall positive review in which she praised the script's "offbeat lines and unexpected laughs", but noted there is still an "underlying high-and-mighty moral tone, which might have come straight from the pen of
Hawthorne -- a puritannical posture wholly deserving of Madeline's retort: 'Blah, blah, blah, blah.' Really, fellas, what's a little cucumber mask going to hurt?" In
Newsweek,
David Ansen wrote, "Oddly, the more fantastical and grotesque this comedy becomes, the more conventional it seems-and the less it has to say. Somewhere in the middle of the movie, the characters take a back seat to the pyrotechnics, reality is replaced by cliffhangers and Gothic claptrap, and the laughs start to dry up. Satire needs a social context, but the filmmakers have little to say about the culture that created these age-obsessed women. Still, even when 'Death Becomes Her' wanders off course, it remains worth rooting for."
Accolades Legacy Death Becomes Her has acquired a significant cult following, especially in the
LGBT community. At
RogerEbert.com, Jessica Ritchey wrote, "Time has been kind to 'Death Becomes Her', and the mordantly funny eye it turns to Hollywood pretense and our cultural inability to forgive women for aging. With the virtual extinction of Hollywood's interest in women over thirty, it's a real pleasure to see a film centered on and held down by two actresses as strong as Streep and Hawn." An article in
Vanity Fair titled "The Gloriously Queer Afterlife of 'Death Becomes Her called the film a "gay cult classic" and "a touchstone of the queer community". The movie is screened in bars during
Pride Month, while the characters of Madeline and Helen are favorites of drag performers. In this vein, the film inspired a
Death Becomes Her-themed runway show on
season 7 of ''
RuPaul's Drag Race. and in 2018 she played Madeline in a drag stage show parody called "Drag Becomes Her" alongside season 6 contestant BenDeLaCreme. Tom Campbell, an executive producer of RuPaul's Drag Race'', reflected on the appeal of the movie to gay audiences: In May 2024, ''RuPaul's Drag Race's''
Trinity the Tuck and
Jujubee released their single
'Til Death Becomes Us" alongside a music video, serving as an homage to the original film. Rotten Tomatoes lists the film on its 100 Best Zombie Movies, ranked by Tomatometer. ==Musical==