The rationale for the designated hitter rule arose early in the history of professional baseball. During the 1880s, an increased emphasis on improving the specialized skill of pitching contributed to a decline in pitcher
batting averages. In 1891, during negotiations surrounding the merger of the
American Association and
National League, team executives J. Walter Spalding of
New York and
William Chase Temple of
Pittsburgh proposed competing ideas to eliminate the pitcher from the batting order. however, his proposal received little support. Pitchers rejected the idea of giving up hitting. In 1910,
Addie Joss stated, "if there is one thing that a pitcher would rather do than make the opposing batsmen look foolish, it is to step to the plate, especially in a pinch, and deliver the much-needed hit." Nevertheless, in the late 1920s, National League president
John Heydler made several attempts to introduce a 10th-man designated hitter as a way to add more offense to the game. For the first time since 1908, the
American and National Leagues had a collective batting average below .240;
Carl Yastrzemski led the American League in hitting with only a .301 mark. After the season, in order to increase offensive output, the height of the
pitcher's mound was reduced from , and the upper limit of the
strike zone was lowered from the top of a batter's shoulders to his armpits. In 1969, the
International League and four other minor leagues began a four-year trial period for the designated hitter. The American League allowed its use in spring training in 1971, however, when the minor league trial period ended, the American and National Leagues could not agree on implementation. The National League chose not to implement the DH; it was intended for the two leagues to agree on a common rule at the end of the American League's trial. As expected, the American League posted a higher batting average than the National League in 1973. This trend held in every season in which the American League employed the designated hitter but the National League did not between 1973 and 2021. the National League held a vote on August 13, 1980, to determine whether or not to adopt it. A majority of the 12 member teams was necessary to pass the rule, and the measure was expected to pass. However, when the teams were informed that the rule would not take effect until the 1982 season,
Philadelphia Phillies vice president
Bill Giles was unsure of how the team owner,
Ruly Carpenter, wanted him to vote. Unable to contact Carpenter, who was on a fishing trip, Giles was forced to abstain from voting. Five days after that meeting, the Cardinals fired their general manager,
John Claiborne, who was the leading proponent for the adoption of the DH rule, and the National League never held another vote on the issue. The designated hitter was not used in the
World Series from 1973 to 1975. This trend continued, even with the eventual onset of the universal designated hitter. The Astros moved to the American League in 2013, giving each league 15 teams and requiring interleague play throughout the entire season. There was debate within MLB to unify the rules of the two leagues, with either the American League returning to its pre-1973 rules and having the pitcher hit or the National League adopting the DH. In January 2016, MLB commissioner
Rob Manfred indicated that consideration was given to the National League adopting the DH for the 2017 season, when a new collective bargaining agreement would take effect. However, he later backtracked, saying that he did not envision such a change being made in the near future. Accordingly, the DH rule was not then adopted by the National League. In 2020, in an attempt to avoid overtaxing pitchers and lessen the
impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, the National League used the DH for the first time. For the first time since 1972 (the final year before the American League adopted the DH), the National League had the higher seasonal batting average of the two leagues. On April 4, 2021, an American League team voluntarily declined to use a designated hitter in their starting lineup for the first time since 1976, when the
Los Angeles Angels placed starting pitcher
Shohei Ohtani second in the batting order. This was also the first time since 1903 that a pitcher had been listed as the second hitter in the starting lineup. On June 23, 2021, Ohtani made history again when, for the first time, an AL team did not use the designated hitter and an NL team did. While the Angels declined the DH privilege, the visiting Giants opted to use it, starting
Alex Dickerson at DH. On February 10, 2022, Manfred announced plans for a universal DH beginning with the
2022 season. The rule was ratified as part of a new collective bargaining agreement with the MLBPA on March 10, 2022, after which both leagues have continuously employed the designated hitter. ==Debate==