He was later editor of the
Matlock Mercury, where he became involved in the campaign to overturn the
murder conviction of
Stephen Downing. In 1973, Downing, at the time a 17-year-old with the reading age of an 11-year-old, was imprisoned for the murder of Wendy Sewell and served 27 years in jail. Following his six-year campaign, the conviction was eventually quashed and declared unsafe by the
Court of Appeal in 2001 and Downing was released.
In Denial of Murder changes Hale's work on the case eventually helped to force a change in both European and British law, allowing any prisoner, particularly in denial of murder (IDOM) and/or convicted of any serious offence, to be allowed to appeal for parole consideration directly to the Parole Board. Downing's case was one of three test cases originally presented to the
European Court of Human Rights by barrister
Edward Fitzgerald. After several years of debate and despite a late appeal from the British Government, the case went in Downing's favour and he received £500 in compensation. When the murder conviction was later quashed, Downing also received over £900,000 in compensation. Hale's first book about the Stephen Downing appeal case,
Town Without Pity, became a best-seller. It was adapted into a BBC TV drama starring
Stephen Tompkinson and
Caroline Catz called
In Denial of Murder. In 2016 Judge Robert Rinder featured Hale's updated, revised, and informative book 'Murder in the Graveyard' published by HarperCollins, and featured Hale's long quest for justice within a one-hour special on ITV 1 for Judge Rinder's Crime series. The show was repeated in July 2018. Taking part were Hale, Stephen Downing and a cold case detective Chris Clark, who believes Wendy Sewell, the victim in the Bakewell murder, for which Downing was eventually cleared, may have been another victim of the notorious Yorkshire Ripper Peter Sutcliffe. It was 2019, when Hale was asked by publishers HarperCollins to write his exclusive and heavily updated version of his original story about his successful campaign work on the Stephen Downing appeal case. The book entitled
Murder in the Graveyard contained new and updated information about his long discovery to find the evidence that helped to quash Downing's conviction, and revealed a number of compelling clues and fresh evidence that indicated who may have been responsible for the brutal murder of Wendy Sewell in September 1973.
Awards Hale was voted 2001 Man of the Year by
The Observer newspaper, Journalist of the Year by
What the Papers Say and was made an
OBE for his efforts and campaigning journalism. He also won numerous other journalistic awards including regional and national awards. ==Other cases==