Dorothy's Broadway debut was in 1923 in
Jerome Kern’s
Stepping Stones in which she played the character of Roughette Hood among a cast which included her father,
Fred Stone (as Peter Plug), Oscar Ragland (as Otto DeWolfe), and
Jack Whiting (as Captain Paul). She was a big hit in the show and
The New York Times reported that the audience was cheering her before the first act was over. Dorothy performed with her father again at the Globe Theater in
Manhattan, in
Criss Cross in October 1926. This was followed by
Three Cheers in 1928 (with
Will Rogers taking her father's place because of an airplane accident). The headline of the review by Brooks Atkinson in the New York Times read "Dorothy Stone Captivates as Dancer and Singer." In August, 1929, when
Ruby Keeler (
Al Jolson's wife) had to withdraw due to illness from the cast of Ziegfeld's
Show Girl, Dorothy took over to headlines that read "Dorothy Stone scores a hit on 'Show Girl' (...) receives an Ovation." Dorothy next appeared with her father (having recovered from his accident), mother, and Paula (making her stage debut) in
Ripples, a show which debuted in
New Haven, Connecticut, in January 1930. The first New York production of the show came to the
New Amsterdam Theater in February. As Brooks Atkinson of the New York Times reported, "Fred Stone is back." Dorothy, Paula, and their father teamed in
Smiling Faces, produced by the
Shubert Theater owners in 1932.
Mack Gordon and
Harry Revel wrote the music and lyrics. The musical had its pre-Broadway tryout in
Springfield, Massachusetts. Dorothy took over the roles played by
Marilyn Miller in the
Irving Berlin musical,
As Thousands Cheer in 1934. "She tossed them off with charm and with the sprightly air that is the trade-mark of the Stones." With her husband,
Charles Collins, Dorothy appeared in the musical comedy
Sea Legs (1937), which got bad notices. About Charles and Dorothy, however, Brooks Atkinson said they "are an attractive couple with a neat gift for dancing." She played Essie in the 1945 revival of ''
You Can't Take It with You'' in which her father (at age 70) appeared as Martin Vanderhof, and her husband, Charles Collins, as Boris Kolenkhov. She also appeared with her husband and
Eddie Foy, Jr. in the revival of
The Red Mill in 1945. ==Film career==